sardinia vs sicily travel

Sicily vs Sardinia: which Italian island should you escape to?

Jan 19, 2023 • 9 min read

The secluded beaches of Sardinia, or the historic monuments of Sicily? Our writers will help you decide © iStock

Some countries are blessed. And then there’s Italy , which is endowed with not one but two huge island regions in the Mediterranean .

Both filled with churches, vineyards, churches and sites testifying to millennia of history, Sicily and Sardinia are nonetheless truly distinct – and truly wonderful. Having trouble picking between the two? We’ve asked two partisans to go to the mat for their picks.

Sicily: savor its sumptuous soul

A Lonely Planet Italy expert for more than a decade, Nicola Williams lives a scenic flit through the Mont Blanc Tunnel from il bel paese . Her favorite Sicilian journeys are those where time slowly stills.

Yes, certain spots in  Sicily have all the dazzling beauty and million-dollar glamour of a Hollywood movie star. (Knowing the island inside out as I do, it’s honestly a no-brainer why The White Lotus team decamped here to film the second season of HBO’s breakout hit.) But it is in fact Sicily’s gutsy soul, ravishing virgin landscapes and cultural treasures that make it so utterly captivating and irresistible as a holiday destination. I challenge anyone to step foot on Sicilian soil and not leave with a burning desire to return.

My first Sicilian escapade was with my family moons ago. We sailed into the small but busy port of  Trapani one April and spent two gloriously warm weeks roaming the less-explored west of the island: learning to harvest salt along the  Via del Sal , hiking mule tracks in the remote Madonie mountains, running wild through meadows of sun-yellow fennel around  Segesta’s majestic Greek-temple ruins . The fact we didn’t even make it to uber-chic  Isola Bella , glitzy  Taormina or baroque beauty  Noto (all now of White Lotus fame) was completely incidental. Sicily had me hooked.

I’ve spent countless weeks since digging deep into Sicily’s green soul: again with the kids; solo; and in the depths of winter, when snow caps  Mt Etna and blood-red pomegranates ripen. During last August’s apocalyptic heatwave, Sicily’s paradise-like beaches were my second home. If you think it’s all dreamy sweeps of soft golden sand polka-dotted with parasols and hawkers roasting ears of corn to order, think again. Seaside Cefalù on the  Tyrrhenian Coast is a shameless heartthrob, with its cinematic sands and honied old town showcasing one of Sicily’s greatest Arab-Norman architectural masterpieces.

Snorkeling off sun-scorched rocks with locals on Capo Cefalù, uncovering tiny pebble coves cradling emerald waters in the  Riserva Naturale dello Zingaro , and clambering across wave-splashed rocks to  Capo Milazzo ’s natural piscina (swimming pool) in the sea are all equally awe-inspiring. And if it’s high-octane natural beauty and solitude you’re after, simply set your compass south to the wild and windswept seashore of the WWF-protected Riserva Naturale di Torre Salsa on Sicily’s Mediterranean coast. 

Then, of course, there’s Sicily’s sublime islands: the Egadi and  Aeolian archipelagos. Volcano aficionados naturally gravitate to “mainland” Etna – the Wine Train is a brilliant chance for families and less-active travelers to eyeball the explosive peak close up. But it’s the spectacular nightly fireworks on back-to-basics  Stromboli that’s the sneaky heart-stealer. Whether you’re hiking up its volcano at sunset, flopping on a black beach or watching a rooftop movie beneath the stars at 1950s Hotel Villaggio Stromboli , you feel the car-free island’s primeval force sizzling off every last volcanic rock and grain of black sand. I love breakfast and aperitivo at buzzy Il Canneto and raw fish at after-dark hotspot L’Angolo del Pesce. A half-hour hydrofoil ride away, fashionista  Panarea is the manicured yin to Stromboli’s rough-cut yang. Drink in the insanely chic vibe over cocktails – Italianate shades firmly on – at Bridge Ammare overlooking Baia Zimmari. 

Sorry, Sardinia: you simply can’t compete with Sicily’s Herculean cultural heritage. Outside of Greece , nowhere else in Europe summons the ancient world with such drama. Greek temple ruins at  Selinunte , Segesta and  Agrigento ’s Valley of the Temples are unbelievably well preserved. But watching a classical tragedy unfold on stage at  Syracuse ’s ancient  theater really is something else entirely. Ditto for the island’s cache of baroque towns and spellbinding collection of Roman, Byzantine and Arab-Norman mosaics (you only need to visit Unesco-listed  Villa Romana del Casale or  Cattedrale di Monreale to get the picture).

I’ve saved waxing lyrical about Sicily’s unpretentious grassroots cuisine until last in case you need to set off for lunch. In all honesty, it’s hard to know where to begin: a beefy spleen bun from a pushcart at one of Palermo’s intoxicating, souk-like  markets , or a paper cone of battered frittura mista (deep-fried seafood) from one of  Catania ’s traditional fish vendors? Mulberry granita and a sweet brioche bun by the sea at Da Alfredo’s on Salina ? Lobster soup and couscous-esque frascatole at Trattoria Il Veliero on Marettimo? Michelin-starred gastronomy in  caves in Ragusa Ibla or a  Renaissance art studio in Palermo? Decadent cannoli and dolci (cakes) to simply die for all over the island?

Eat your heart out, Sardinia.

Sardinia: into the wild unknown 

Kerry Walker has made Sardinia her spiritual home in the Mediterranean over the past decade and has co-authored the Lonely Planet Sardinia and Italy guidebooks.

Sicily has hogged the limelight for long enough. The island is so ridiculously popular and so frequently splashed across screens – from the family drama of The Godfather to the secrets of the hideously super-rich in The White Lotus – you feel you know it before you even arrive. And while Sicily’s allure is undeniable, it can suffer from the mass tourism curse. Come summer, it’s simply swamped. 

And  Sardinia ? What do you know about this island? My guess is not a lot – unless you happen to have been there. You might have heard about the jet-set haven of the Costa Smeralda , where celebs with mega-yachts escape the paparazzi – but other than that, niente . Because while Sicily has been busy blowing its own trumpet (and its volcanic top), its less showy cousin is happy to stay in the sidelines and whisper quietly about its charms.

But my, what charms! I’ve traveled pretty much every inch of Sardinia over the past decade, and I swear this is the island of your wildest Mediterranean dreams. So put Sicily out of your mind for a minute, and follow me. 

Let’s start with the beaches, shall we? Sardinia has some of the most insanely beautiful spiaggie you’ll find without stepping foot off European shores. They’re often likened to the Caribbean, but why imagine yourself anywhere else? Time and again I’m blown away by the east coast  Golfo di Orosei ’s exquisite bays, many of which can only be reached on foot or by boat. Here, ragged limestone cliffs dive to flour-white sands and a sea so turquoise it looks Photoshopped.

On the north coast,  La Maddalena ’s pink granite islands hide sublime coves and ruffled azure waters. Then there is La Cinta , with bleached sands sloping into cerulean seas and a lagoon fizzing with flamingos, and the Costa Smeralda’s astonishing  Spiaggia del Principe . Heading west reveals the great dunes and waves of the  Costa Verde , while south-coast  Is Arutas sparkles with an arc of frost-white quartz sand. Choosing a favorite is impossible. I swear.

But the beaches are just tip-of-the-iceberg stuff. Sure, Sicily has Mt Etna – yet Sardinia is just as wild, mountainous and ripe for adventure. Spring brings the magic touch, with wildflowers lighting up the slopes and coast. Go then and you’ll get the island’s trails largely to your lucky self. Great hiking is plentiful, but the uphill scramble through a lush, silent valley to the mysterious Bronze Age ruins of  Tiscali , and the trek to  Gola Su Gorropu , where 400m(1312ft)-high walls of sheer limestone rise above a boulder-strewn gorge that’s often billed “Europe’s Grand Canyon,” are unmissable. Italy’s toughest trek? Heading off the radar on the week-long Selvaggio Blu trek on Golfo di Orosei is epic, involving climbing, abseiling, route finding and camping by a starlit sea as if you were the last person left on earth.

If you prefer action by the water, it’s all here: from some of Europe’s best DWS (deep-water soloing) to windsurfing; surfing; kitesurfing; diving the coral-filled, cathedral-like depths of the Nereo Cave, the largest underwater grotto in the Mediterranean; or kayaking to your own private cove on the island’s east coast.

Sicily’s cities get all the fuss, but Sardinia can rival them for culture – and they’re generally less crowded and chaotic. Take  Alghero , with its honey-colored sea walls, Gothic palazzi, cafe-lined piazzas and palpable Spanish vibe, for instance. And I love heading up to the rock-hugging ramparts of  Cagliari ’s Il Castello district for a sundowner at dusk, when the sky pinkens, the Pisan towers glow gold and locals head out for an evening passeggiata (stroll) among medieval citadel walls.

Historically, you might think Sicily has the ace with its Greek temples and Byzantine mosaics, but Sardinia has many surprises up its sleeves. Namely 7000 megalithic nuraghi , Bronze and Iron Age towers and settlements that include tombe dei giganti (“giant's grave” tombs), pozzi sacri (sacred wells) and domus de janas (fairy houses) straight out of a kids’ story. One is a Unesco World Heritage site ( Nuraghe Su Nuraxi ) – though the real thrill of prehistory here is that you just happen upon it, as if a 4000-year-old temple plonked in a farmer’s field were no big deal.

Ah, but what about the food, you say? Again, you might think Sicily had the edge, but some of my most memorable meals have been on Sardinia, an island that embraced slow food long before it became a trend. The pasta here is sensational: sun-dried, couscous-like fregola ; shell-shaped malloreddus swimming in rich tomato, garlic, basil and saffron sauce; and ravioli-like culurgiones , stuffed with pecorino and mint. And the seafood? Divine. Try sea urchins and lobster from Alghero, giant gamberi rossi (red prawns) and Cabras bottarga (mullet roe). Agriturismi (farmstays) dish up spectacular feasts: antipasti, pasta, porceddu (suckling pig slow-roasted over juniper or myrtle) and seadas , honey-drenched fritters filled with ricotta and lemon zest that are – dare I say it – even more delicious than cannoli. 

Good news: you can drink the local Cannonau wine with a clean conscience. The full-bodied, antioxidant-packed red is one of the reasons the island’s mountainous interior is one of the world’s five “blue zones” – places of extraordinary longevity, with incredibly high percentages of centenarians. No wonder: there is so much here to live for.

Explore related stories

Tips & Advice

May 24, 2024 • 4 min read

Local travel writers share their favorite lesser-known places to visit in Italy.

May 4, 2024 • 4 min read

Apr 27, 2024 • 5 min read

Apr 19, 2024 • 10 min read

Apr 17, 2024 • 6 min read

Apr 15, 2024 • 10 min read

Mar 30, 2024 • 4 min read

Mar 26, 2024 • 6 min read

Mar 26, 2024 • 4 min read

Mar 21, 2024 • 6 min read

Urban Abroad

Urban Planning and Travel Blog

Sicily vs Sardinia: Which to Visit?

Travel Blog Last Updated · Jan 14th, 2023 [post_author_posts_link] · [post_comments before=""] -->

When comparing Sicily vs Sardinia which do you choose?

It’s getting harder to decide where to spend holidays in such a beautiful country like Italy, but even harder when it comes to these two islands!

Sicily and Sardinia are the two largest islands in the Mediterranean Sea and they’re both parts of Italy. In the last couple of years, they also became popular destinations for both Italian tourists and international travelers.

Table of Contents

Sicily vs Sardinia

Even if they do happen to have quite a few things in common, they’re also quite different at the same time. Not to mention, those differences can make you better understand if you could be more into the vibe of Sicily or Sardinia.

So, keep reading our comparison post below to learn more about these two Italian islands to visit and exactly what to expect when traveling there.

Sicily vs Sardinia: Which is better?

Sicily, a stunning volcanic island and melting-pot of Mediterranean populations and Sardinia, the most esoteric place in Italy, are known for some of the best beaches in the whole world. Which one is better?

Best time to visit Sicily vs Sardinia

The climate on the two islands is quite similar . Along the coasts, you can expect to find a mild climate in winter and hot in summer . The average temperatures during summer for both islands are between 26 and 30 °C .

In the Sardinian inland areas, you can find lower temperatures, especially in the hills and mountains. The climatic area of the Etna area is alpine, making this part of Sicily a unique one compared to the rest of the region.

Here winters are freezing with temperatures reaching -12 °C and summers are cold, with an average of 6 °C. The best time to visit both islands is during the summer so you can spend time at the beach.

This time of the year is also ideal to explore cities and villages based on the coast, making the most of the sunny days and the pleasant sea breeze. The months of April and May are suitable for hiking and visiting cities too .

Culture in Sicily vs Sardinia

Comparing the north and south of Italy is one thing, but it’s common to read around the web that Sardinia is culturally less interesting compared to Sicily.

Believe it or not, many people say that the only reason worth traveling to Sardinia for is just for its beaches, we believe that’s incorrect!

We can guarantee you that both islands have an incredibly rich cultural heritage. Sicily is known for the archaeological sites in particular the Temple Valley in Agrigento, the charm of cities like Cefalù and Syracuse .

Let’s not forget about Erice , the medieval village in the mountains, and the volcano Etna, the symbol of the region. Sicily is nothing less than an exciting encounter between nature, history and archaeology.

Palermo , the capital city, has always represented a cultural hub where the Norman, Phoenicians, Greeks and Roman cultures met over the centuries.

Sardinia is a mysterious and partly unknown place to visit, but extremely rich of archaeological sites belonging to the pre-Nuragic and Nuragic civilizations as well to the Phoenicians, Carthaginians and Romans.

As we said earlier, it’s not all about beaches. Among the top cultural destinations to visit in Sardinia some of out favorites are listed below.

Sardinia Famous Landmarks:

• Nuragic palace of Barumini
• Church of Santa Sabina
• Nuragic complex of Santa Cristina or Santa Vittoria
• Complex of Tiscali
• Gorroppu and the Gennargentu

It is easy to combine some trekking activities and archaeology here. There’s also a wide range of villages in Sardinia and all of them are characterized by their unique traditions and folklore .

We can certainly say that Sardinia has more prehistoric attractions than Sicily, but both are absolutely a place to visit for their culture and traditions.

Food in Sicily vs Sardinia

When it comes to food, it’s pretty hard to decide between Sicily and Sardinia. Both regions have their own culinary traditions worth getting to know.

No need to remind you that in their fertile lands grow the best lemons, oranges, tomatoes and grapes and sea offers the most incredible seafood to eat fresh, every single day.

Sicily is the island of the best cannoli and cassata , arancini, fresh tuna and swordfish, pasta with sardines and the one with fried aubergines called ‘alla norma’. In Catania you can do food tours and learn all about the food culture.

But what about Sardinia? The Italian island is home of the delicious roasted suckling pig, carasau and guttiau breads, seeds to eat with honey, pecorino cheese and bottarga and culurgiones , just to name a few!

Long story short, the Sicilian and Sardinian cuisines will definitely leave their marks on your memory.

Cost of Travel in Sicily vs Sardinia

The cheapest island region to travel to is Sicily . Flights and accommodation are overall more expensive in Sardinia than in Sicily and that’s something to take into consideration when deciding where to go.

If you’re traveling on a budget then it’s probably better to go to Sicily, even though by booking in advance you can find good deals for Sardinia too.

Both islands’ main cities are well-connected to international destinations such as London, Paris and Brussels and most Italian airports and are served by low-cost airlines like Ryanair and Easyjet.

In Sicily, the main airports are based in Palermo and Catania, whilst in Sardinia are in Cagliari, Olbia and Alghero. You can also get to both islands by ferry and it’s a good option if you want to get there to move around with your car. Check out these rent-a-car deals before you make a final decision.

But just so you know, most of the time, it’s just cheaper to get a flight from wherever you’re in Italy at that time. During the high season, accommodation prices can be in both islands quite expensive but Sicily is a bit cheaper.

Eating out costs more or less the same in both islands and nightlife is particularly expensive in some parts of Sardinia like the Costa Smeralda.

Things to do in Sicily vs Sardinia

The list of things to do in Sicily and Sardinia is endless. Both islands are great beach destinations and you can find stunning golden and white sands around both coasts.

But it’s not all about sun and sea here, as you can also spend time hanging around the historical city centers of beautiful cities like Cagliari and Alghero in Sardinia and Palermo or Catania in Sicily. Both islands are dotted with small and quaint villages with many of them located on the coast.

They’re also great destinations for water sports, in particular snorkeling and diving thanks to the pristine seabeds and abundance of sea life.

It’s also easy to plan beach day trips from where you’re based, for example to explore the stunning La Maddalena archipelago, leaving from Palau or the Tavolara island , leaving from Sos Aranzos – Golfo Aranci, if you’re in Sardinia.

In Sicily, you can join guided trekking to visit the Volcano Etna or go for a day in the Aeolian islands of Lipari, Salina or Panarea.

Tourist attractions in Sicily vs Sardinia

The main tourist attractions in Sicily and Sardinia are the beaches followed by the historical city centers and archaeological sites.

In both islands, there’s a vast offer of beaches . Among the best Sicilian beaches, you can find the Spiaggia dei Conigli in Lampedusa and the Cala Rossa in Favignana .

In Sardinia, some of the most incredible ones are the Pelosa in Stintino , in the province of Sassari, Cala Mariolu in Baunei and Porto Giunco in Villasimius .

Sardinia is a popular destination for VIPs, so don’t be surprised to spot yachts in the Costa Smeralda area where accommodation, restaurants and entertainment is more expensive than in the rest of the island. While in Palermo the hop-on hop-off bus tour makes it easy to explore the culture.

There are also less expensive places to stay like the Costa Verde , with a rich Mediterranean vegetation and cliffs overlooking the sea. Culturally, these two regions offer a lot to tourists.

Agrigento, Etna, Erice, Syracuse with the Ortigia island, Palermo, Ragusa are placed in Sicily known all over the world for their Baroque beauty and the chilled vibe you can breathe here.

Sardinia is home to the ‘ nuraghi ‘ that you can visit by moving towards the internal part of the island.

Some of the unmissable ones are the palace of Barumini and the complex of Santa Cristina . Among the best cities to visit in Sardinia, you should certainly add Alghero and Cagliari on the list.

Getting Around Sicily vs Sardinia

The best way to move around both in Sicily and Sardinia is by car. For many, renting a car is the best option as public transport can be unreliable and it could affect your travel plans and your precious time in these islands.

Trains and buses are connect the major cities and some tourist attractions, but that might require multiple changes and you can also expect frequent delays.

If renting a car, we highly recommend getting the full car insurance that can protect you from any accidents and from getting the car stolen.

Driving in cities like a Palermo it’s all about having steady nerves and being extra careful as the usual road rules are widely not respected.

In general, hiring a car is less expensive in Sicily than in Sardinia but if traveling during the summer months in both regions can be quite expensive.

So, when comparing Sicily vs Sardinia, which is one is best?

In our eyes, there’s no easy answer to this question as both regions are worth visiting . Travel budget is a key factor when it comes to deciding where to spend your time and Sicily is slightly less expensive compared to Sardinia.

Sicily vs Sardinia: Which will you visit?

Whether you are more a beach type of person or one that loves exploring the city centers and villages, Sicily and Sardinia are both great places to visit that offer a great amount of things to do and see .

In these islands, you can find the best beaches in Italy and in Europe and learn about ancient civilizations that colonized these lands centuries ago.

There’s no right answer, but it depends on your budget , available connections from where you’re based and what you’re more interested in getting to know.

If you’re like many other travelers who are somewhat concerned about safety in Sicily then be sure to read our expansive guide on what places to avoid.

Dear responsible traveler : This post may contain affiliate links, which means, if you click through and make a purchase, book a tour or a hotel, we may earn a small commission. This is at no additional cost to you . Your support means a lot and helps us to maintain the quality of this site.

Sharing is caring!

Recent Posts

• How to get from Treviso Airport to Venice
• How to get from Verona to Lake Garda
• Marco Polo Airport to Venice
• Is Guadalajara safe?
• Living Abroad
• Sustainability
• Travel Blog

Privacy Overview

• Visit Oyster on Facebook!
• Visit Oyster on Pinterest!
• Visit Oyster on Instagram!
• Visit Oyster on Twitter!
• Subscribe to stay up to date!

Yes, send me expert tips and deals!

By proceeding, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use .

• Subtract one room 1 Rooms Add one room
• Subtract one adult 2 Adults Add one adult

Sicily or Sardinia: Which Is a Better Vacation Spot for You?

See recent posts by Anne Olivia Bauso

Centro Vacanze Isuledda in Sardinia

Sicily and Sardinia are the two largest islands in the Mediterranean, in that order. Both are part of Italy, and both are popular vacation destinations for mainland Italians and international travelers wanting beautiful beaches, delicious food and wine, charming small towns , archeological sites, and warm sunshine. However, for all their similarities, there are some key differences between Sicily and Sardinia that might steer you to one island or the other. We stack the two head to head, so that you can determine which one is right for your Mediterranean island vacation.

Hotels in this story

Culture in Sicily and Sardinia

View from Ambasciatori Hotel in Palermo

Sicily: Sicily is quite literally a grab bag of cultures and civilizations. The island was the Times Square of the ancient world, with colonists, visitors, and invaders from all over Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East passing through. Over the past many thousand years, the island has been conquered and governed by the ancient Greeks, Romans, Vandals, Byzantines, Arabs, Normans, French, British, and Spanish, and each ruler has left an indelible mark on Sicily — architecturally, gastronomically, or otherwise. In the capital city of Palermo , you can climb to the roof of the main cathedral — a marvelous layer cake of Norman, Moorish, Gothic, Baroque, and Neoclassical styles — before getting lost in the souk-like maze of the Ballaro market. In Taormina , you can climb up to an ancient Greco-Roman theater overlooking the sea and Mount Etna . And in Agrigento ’s Valley of the Temples (a UNESCO World Heritage site) and other spots on the island’s west coast, you can see some of the most pristine Greek temples. In fact, there are more surviving Greek temples in Sicily than there are in Greece. 

Sardinia: It’s safe to say that Sardinia can’t compete with Sicily, culture-wise. But Sardinia is no cultural slouch. The Sardinian city of Olbia was a major seaport in the Middle Ages; today, you can visit Olbia’s 11th-century basilica, an archeological museum with ancient Roman ships on display, and ruins from the times of the Phoenicians and the Carthaginians. The Duomo of Cagliari is a pretty Romanesque church dating back to the 1200s. Sardinia is also home to the archeological site of Nuraghe Palmavera, a complex of stone towers, chambers, and passages built in the Bronze and Iron Ages. 

Food in Sardinia and Sicily

Su Gologone Experience Hotel in Sardinia

Sicily: Almost everything about Sicily lends itself to the fact that it is one of the best foodie destinations in the world. A volcanic island in the heart of the Mediterranean, Sicily benefits from constant sunshine, fertile lava-laced soil, and three surrounding bodies of water teeming with seafood. If it’s an edible tree, plant, or vine, Sicilians can grow it: Olives, almonds, wheat, lemons, oranges, figs, plums, apricots, pistachios, and tomatoes flourish across the island. Not only are the climate and geography perfect for cultivating food, but Sicily is also the recipient of centuries of cultural influences. Many Sicilian dishes, such as fish couscous and stuffed swordfish rolls, have a Arabic or North African bent. The quintessential Sicilian street food arancini combines rice and saffron, two ingredients introduced by the Arabs ( arancini are commonly served with meat ragu stuffed inside — a twist from the French). The raisins and pine nuts that star in the classic pasta con le sarde were both known to Sicily, but the combination is distinctly Arab.

Sardinia: Like Sicily, Sardinia is an island in the Mediterranean, so it enjoys a pleasant climate that vegetation like eggplant and artichoke can’t resist and miles of coastline that bring in seafood like cuttlefish, octopus, clams, shrimp, lobster, and tuna. And like Sicily, Sardinia’s history is full of invasions and foreign rule — the Phoenicians, Carthaginians, Romans, Arabs, and Spanish all made their way here, too — swaying the cuisine in countless ways. Popular dishes in Sardinia include porcedu (spit-roasted suckling pig), fregula (a couscous-like semolina pasta influenced by North Africa), and, in the city of Sassari , lumache (snails stuffed with a blend of pecorino, parsley, garlic, bread crumbs, and white wine). 

Wine in Sicily and Sardinia

Quintocanto Hotel & Spa in Sicily

Sicily: The Sicilian soil and sun are godsends for wine-making. The island’s many vineyards and wine estates produce full-bodied reds and whites, including the fragrant Etna Rosso (great with swordfish, salmon, tuna, or even just pasta with tomato sauce); the sweet, caramelly Marsala; and the earthy Nero d’Avola — a specialty of the area around Noto and the most famous of the Sicilian wines. Wine-loving couples could book two or three nights at Monaci delle Terre Nere , an organic farm stay on the slopes of Mount Etna that produces six types of organic wine. The volcano is home to many fantastic producers, both long-established and up-and-coming, including the top-rated wineries Tenuta di Fessina and Fattorie Romeo del Castello. 

Sardinia: Sardinia is blessed with the same hot Mediterranean sun as Sicily, but its wine identity is all its own. Its most famous wine is Cannonau, a berry-scented Grenache that is produced all over the island. Following in its footsteps is the fruity-floral Vermentino (known in Italy’s Piedmont region as Favorita), a crisp and light-bodied white that pairsperfectly with seafood. In the historic jewel Oristano , the wine to try is the warm, dry Vernaccia di Oristano.

Beaches in Sicily and Sardinia

Beach at Centro Vacanze Isuledda in Sardinia

Sicily: Sicily is a volcanic island, so you’ll have to cut it some slack when it comes to its shoreline. Most Sicilian beaches are somewhere between pebbly and full-on jagged rocky — though there are a few notable exceptions, such as Mondello (an easy bus or bike ride from Palermo) and San Vito lo Capo at the northwest tip of the island. But what Sicily generally lacks in broad sweeps of soft white sand, it makes up for with its dramatic coastal beauty, clear blue water, and many spectacular islands. Sicily’s volcanic, UNESCO-protected Aeolian Islands include the popular resort Lipari , the chic millionaire-magnet Panarea , and the aptly named Vulcano , which is famous for its mud baths, black-sand beaches, and views of Mount Etna. Another island chain, the Aegadian, is home to Favignana, where the beaches boast pure white sand and undersea caves that are popular with divers.

Sardinia: The beaches here are some of the best in Europe — on par with top beaches in Spain, Portugal, and Greece. The northern edge of the island is truly breathtaking, with soft white sand and neon-teal waters. Called Costa Smeralda (Emerald Coast), this is one of Sardinia’s most iconic sites. However, Sardinia is ringed with stunning coastline all around; coastal spots that aren’t to be missed include the white-sand Rena Bianca, the vertical cliffs of Capo Caccia (go at sunset), the picturesque and shallow La Cinta, and the paradise that is Cala Sinzias. Take the ferry from Palau to the Maddalena Islands , an archipelago off the north coast of Sardinia with beautiful and mostly empty beaches.

Things to Do in Sicily and Sardinia

Duomo in Catania

Sicily:  When it comes to significant historical attractions and towns from the ancient world, Sicily has the upper hand over Sardinia. There are must-see landmarks or charming hilltop towns on every corner of the island, from the Norman Palace and La Martorana in Palermo in the northwest to Ortigia (the historical center of Syracuse) in the southeast. (Outside of Palermo is Monreale, one of the most beautiful cathedrals in Europe and an incredible combo of Arab, Byzantine, and Norman artistic and architectural styles.) The island’s north and northeast contain the Ancient Theatre of Taormina and the Duomo of Cefalu, while the west coast is home to the Valley of the Temples, a UNESCO World Heritage site that was once among the most opulent of Sicily’s Greek colonies. Of the site’s nine temples, the Temple of Concordia is the largest and best-preserved temple in all of Sicily. And this is all before we get to Sicily’s natural wonders, such as Mount Etna (the largest active volcano in Europe and home to many boutique wineries), cliff-framed beaches, and the many pretty islands offshore.

Sardinia: Sardinia’s cultural attractions pale next to Sicily’s, but it nonetheless boasts enough historic sites and museums for excursions between beach days, wine tours, and nature outings. Travelers usually make a point to see Su Nuraxi di Barumini and Nuraghe Sant’Antine, two Bronze Age archeological sites founded nearly 4,000 years ago. Artifacts from the Bronze Age to the Byzantine are on display at the Museo Archeologico Nazionale in Cagliari , Sardinia’s capital. (While there, be sure to visit San Benedetto, the largest city market in Italy, with vendors selling fresh seafood, heirloom tomatoes, apricots, strawberries, casizolu (Sardinian cow’s milk cheese), rustic breads, and, of course, cannoli filled with ricotta and pistachios.) Sardinia’s other main attractions are its points of natural beauty, such as Porto Istana, a lovely beach under a granite promontory; Porto Giunco, a white-sand beach with flamingos; and Oasi Biderosa, a 2,000-plus-acre nature preserve with pristine coves.

Resorts and Hotels Sardinia in Sicily

Villa Bonocore Maletto in Sicily

Sicily: Sicily isn’t huge on international chains. You’ll find a few H&Ms and McDonald’s in Palermo, of course, and United Colors of Benetton and Ermenegildo Zegna shops in the upscale resort town of Taormina. But the vast majority of Sicilian businesses are independent and locally owned, and that’s definitely a good thing. Of the hotels throughout Sicily, the huge majority are family-owned B&Bs, small villas, independent hotels, or outposts of Italian hotel chains, such as the Milan-based Gruppo UNA and the Lake Garda-based Chincherini Holiday. International chain hotels are few and far between. For example, of the nearly 400 hotels we’ve visited in Sicily, fewer than 30 are part of big international brands like Best Western, NH, Hilton, and Four Points by Sheraton. It’s also worth noting that many hotels here don’t feel the competitive need to constantly renovate or modernize. Several feel very much like time capsules of another decade — as far back as the 1960s and 1950s in the case of Sporting Baia and Taormina Park Hotel , respectively. Don’t expect the latest technology, super-contemporary furnishings, and over-the-top plush luxury, even in the high-end hotels. Also, don’t go the all-inclusive route in Sicily unless you’re okay with a bare-bones version of the experience; most all-inclusives have sad buffets, drinks, and entertainment.

Sardinia: Thanks to Costa Smeralda, once an upmarket getaway for the rich, Sardinia has a plethora of upscale and even truly luxury properties, like the secluded, beachfront Le’a Bianca Luxury Resort and the exclusive and chic boutique Hotel Li Finistreddi . There are charming guesthouses and rustic countryside retreats (like Il Girasole Hotel in Villasimius and Hotel Parco degli Ulivi in Arzachena). If you can tear yourself away from the coastline for a night or two, Su Gologone Experience Hotel is an art-filled, luxurious spa getaway in the rugged countryside of the Supramonte foothills. 

Getting Around in Sicily and Sardinia

Street at La Locanda del Conte Mameli in Sardinia

Sicily: To really see Sicily, renting a car is the only way to go. Be sure to splurge on the highest amount of collision protection; even if this coverage doubles your rental-car fees, keep in mind that minor run-ins with other cars is par for the course. There are trains and buses connecting points of interest, but they can be slow and require multiple transfers, both of which gobble up precious time. Driving, however, is not without its challenges. Sicilian roads, especially in the rugged interior, are notoriously curvy; drivers must constantly slow way down to navigate the 180-degree switchbacks. Add sky-high bridges, shoulderless lanes, and sharing the road with speedy Sicilian drivers, and the experience can be slow and a little scary. Prepare for seemingly short distances to take longer than you think. Budget at least half a day (and that’s with no major stops) to get from one coast to the other.

Sardinia: Like Sicily, driving a rental car is the best way to get around in Sardinia. Trains and buses are an option, but they can be a major time suck and not very reliable. Driving yourself is certainly the most efficient way to get around, but it does come with its own set of cons. In addition to paying the base rental rate, you’ll also need to spring on the max insurance and budget for gas costs (fuel is expensive in Italy) and parking. 

You’ll Also Like:

• 12 Rookie Mistakes to Avoid On Your Sicily Vacation
• The 11 Best Beach Towns in Italy
• The Best Italian Islands: Your Guide on Where to Go

All products are independently selected by our writers and editors. If you buy something through our links, Oyster may earn an affiliate commission.

Top Stories

• Travel Tips

Top 11 Las Vegas Hotels on the Strip for Every Type of Traveler

By Christina Vercelletto

• Destination Cheat Sheets

Where to Go in Maine: 11 Places You Should See in Your Lifetime

By Kwin Mosby

• All-Inclusive

9 European Destinations With All-Inclusive Resorts

By Stefanie Waldek

9 Beautiful Caribbean Beaches (And Where to Stay Nearby!)

By Megan Johnson

12 Cheap Alternatives to Expensive Vacation Destinations

By Kevin Brouillard

Travelling Without a Passport

Sicily vs Sardinia: Which Italian Island Paradise is Calling Your Name?

Sometimes, it’s impossible to decide where to go. Let’s break this down and compare Sicily vs Sardinia to find out which island is for you.

Sicily Vs Sardinia: Two incredible Italian islands in the Mediterranean, but which one will you choose for your next tour or solo adventure? We’re sure you’ve heard everyone raving about the perfect white beaches of Sardinia (because they really are amazing), and perhaps the secret is out about the charming villages and delicious food of its friendly neighbor, Sicily?

From spectacular ocean views in every direction, food and wine to make you weak at the knees and buzzing capital cities, it’s fair to say that Sardinia and Sicily share similar traits.

With both islands in such close proximity to mainland Europe , the only question for you is which one should you choose for your well-earned vacation?

Feeling inspired to start the adventure? Take a look at the most popular tours traveling to and through Italy .

Perfectly placed in the heart of the Mediterranean, Sicily has been seducing visitors for the longest time. Charming villages, ancient ruins, grand cities drenched in history, beautiful beaches and a cuisine that is flavorful, fresh and unique, what is it about this island that keeps travelers returning for again and again?

Travel to: Sicily

The capital of Sicily: Palermo

Palermo is a city with attitude. Best described as noisy, fast, a little grim and chaotic, however, somehow it just works. The best thing to do on a visit here is to just wander around and explore the disorderly crumbling architecture, meander through the boisterous food markets to appreciate the incredibly fresh seafood and fresh produce on offer.  

Did we mention that Palermo has some of the best street food in the world?

My favorite thing about Sicily is really the culture and the idea that it seems to be much less stressful than it is in the United States. I spent some time there in the summer of 2016 when I wrote my book Forty Days in Italy on La Mia Famiglia. I spent time with my family who I never met before and they were just very relaxed. They weren’t in a hurry, the pace was slow, and they enjoyed life, and I found that to be a really great thing about Sicily, that makes me want to go back. That mindset is really powerful. The region of Siracusa is a beautiful area and a lot of people I know tend to gravitate towards Agrigento and Palermo, and those are beautiful as well, but I can tell you that Siracusa is amazing. My family lives there and there are some great places you can visit like Noto and different beautiful beaches. My family is from the small village of Sortino. Siracusa is a great part of Sicily, that I think a lot of people don’t think of first when they think of Sicily. One activity we enjoyed was climbing to the top of the volcano, Mount Etna. It was a beautiful view. We took my kids up there and from the top, you have a really spectacular view of Sicily. – Anthony Fasano, The Italian American Experience

Highlights of Sicily

As Sicily’s second-biggest city, Catania is full of energy and draws visitors in with its youthful atmosphere, trendy restaurants and cool alternative bars. The historic centre of the city is UNESCO World Heritage site.

This area is visually grand, with huge black and white marble buildings and churches towering over the many squares and avenues. The city is watched over by the spectacular Mount Etna, an active volcano with trails leading to the summit.

If you’re close-by Catania, you must visit the stunning hilltop town of Taormina. Spectacularly positioned on the side of a mountain, this is Sicily’s most popular (and most expensive) Summer destination.

Enjoy warm evenings in one of the many super cool outdoor bars, snacking on aperitivo and Aperol spritz whilst watching the world go by.

Located on the Ionian Coast of Sicily, this charming city is known for its rich Greek history and ancient ruins. This includes a historic Greek theatre where plays are still performed and an extensive archaeological park.

Syracuse is a pretty labyrinth of cobbled streets surrounded by Roman, Greek, Baroque and medieval buildings and impressive boulevards.

Look out for tasty arancini balls from small eateries and the world famous lemon granita!

The Aeolian Islands

Located off the big main island of Sicily, these volcanic islands all have their own individual personality, however, they are all pricey to visit.

But don’t let that stop you, because we think they’re certainly worth it. Almost all visitors to the Aeolians come by sea. The major point of departure is Milazzo on the Sicilian ‘mainland’. It’s here that you’ll find regular year-round car ferries and hydrofoils to get here.

Be sure to drive around and explore gorgeous tiny villages surrounding this massive volcano. We’d recommend that you stop to buy a bottle of Nero d’Avola wine (grown in this region and absolutely delicious red wine) and pair it with some fresh Italian bread and antipasto that you can pick up from any town, then treat yourself to a picnic in the Mediterranean sun.

Now that really is living ‘la dolce vita’ (the good life).

See Also: We Rank the Best Islands in Europe for Every Traveller

What you need to know before you go to Sicily

• The official currency is the euro.
• Make sure you’ve got travel insurance (especially if you’re hiring a car).
• Search online and book rooms at a smaller family-run hotel and guesthouses to accommodate you during your stay. It’s much cheaper and it’s nice to keep your money local.
• Eat lots of street food (especially in Palermo) and look out for locally grown ingredients for sale on the side of the roads as you make your way around the island.

Getting Around Sicily

• Car: The most common mode of transport, most visitors will hire a car. This will allow you to stop into smaller villages and towns along the way to really immerse yourself in the Sicilian culture.
• Air: Domestic flights operate frequently and regularly between Palermo and Catania
• Ferry: You can take a ferry from mainland Italy (Naples) to Sicily.

There are a number of reliable ferry and hydrofoil options that run from Milazzo to the Aeolian Islands.

Sardinia, a perfect paradise, positioned in heart of the Mediterranean. It is here that you will find the most spectacular blue waters and white sandy beaches you’ve ever seen. As close to North Africa as it is to the Italian mainland, Sardinia is one of Italy’s top summer destinations.

Aside from world-class beaches, Sardinia welcomes visitors with wild and rugged hiking trails, awesome diving spots for the adventure seekers, a good dose of Roman ruins as well as some incredible cuisine to keep food lovers smiling for ages after they’ve left.

Travel to: Sardinia

I’m a big beach/sea girl (hence currently living on a Thai island), so I loved the amazing beaches and smeralda water off the Sardinian coast. I especially loved renting a small boat and cruising around the Golfo di Orosei. The color of the water was truly incredible and these small beaches were way less crowded (even during the high season) than Spiaggia della Pelosa for example. If you’re a first time traveler to the island, I wouldn’t miss hanging out in Cala Gonone and exploring the nearby beaches along the gulf there. – Michelle, Mishvo in Motion

The capital of Sardinia: Cagliari

This smooth yet unpretentious city is positioned in a curved bay in Sardinia’s south.  If shopping is your thing, enjoy the many stores located in leafy tree-lined boulevards and chic arcades. Look forward to top-notch dining options and trendy bars for evening entertainment.

Everywhere you go in this trendy city, you’ll come across bits left from its rich history: centuries-old churches and museums filled with prehistoric artifacts and ancient Roman ruins and stylish buildings.

See Also: Your Essential Guide for How Much You Should Tip in Europe

Highlights of Sardinia

The main tourist town in the northwest is an appealing port of call with a centre that’s a maze of medieval cobbled stoned lanes, squares and Spanish-style buildings that buzz with life.  

Check out the sand colored sea walls of Alghero, and stop to enjoy drinks and relaxing sea views from here.

Neptunes Grotto

Famous underground stalactite caves located near the town of Alghero, Neptune’s Grotto was discovered in the 18th century when a local fisherman from Sardinia spotted an opening in a cliff while fishing off the coast.

The entrance to the grotto lies only about a meter above the sea level at the foot of huge cliffs, the cave can therefore only be visited when the waters below are calm.

To reach the grotto, you have two options. A stairway cut into the cliff leads you about 650 steps from a car park at the top to the entrance. It’s also accessible via a short boat trip from the port of Alghero.

Garibaldi Museum

The housing complex where Giuseppe Garibaldi, the hero who led several military expeditions fighting for the unification of Italy once resided is now the Garibaldi museum.

The museum is surrounded by vegetation and granite rocks typical of the island of Cabrera, and overlooks the perfectly clear waters of the archipelago of La Maddalena.

Maddalena Archipelago

Consisting of 7 major islands, here you’ll discover waters that are crystal clear and pristine.

Castelsardo

The town of Castelsardo is a quaint medieval village, just oozing charm and history. At the top of the village is Doria Castle, which is the focal point of the village.

Nuraghe of Barumini

A megalithic complex built by the Nuragic people 3,500 years ago, which served as a fortified dwelling against invaders. Super cool!

Beaches… are everywhere! Here are a few of our favorite spots:

• Isola Budelli, the Spiaggia di Cavalieri with white sand beaches and pristine waters.
• The resort town of San Teodoro located south of Olbia
• Chia’s beaches on the south coast and Spiaggia della Pelosa.

What you need to know before you go to Sardinia

• Be armed with some good sunblock and summer wear, you’ll be spending lots of time outside.  

Getting around Sardinia

• Car: The most common mode of transport, most visitors will hire a car. This will allow you to stop in smaller beaches and tiny towns along the way.
• Air: Domestic flights operate frequently and regularly between Cagliari, Alghero and Olbia
• Ferry: There are a number of reliable ferry options that run from mainland Italy to several ports in Sardinia.

Useful Phrases and Words in Italy

Where will you go? Sardinia or Sicily? 

Rach is a self-confessed food traveller. When she’s not searching for the best food experiences around the globe, you can find her chasing the sun, taking road trips in her camper-van or chowing down on the best eats around Melbourne. You can follow her adventures on Instagram @veryhungrynomads , Twitter @veryhungrynomads and Very Hungry Nomads

Related Articles

• Food & Drink

Your Guide to Amsterdam’s Secret Bars and Speakeasies

One of the most popular cities in Europe, Amsterdam has no...

• North America

Your Guide to Easter Around the World

Easter is a time to celebrate new beginnings. The symbols and...

• Central America

The Best Spring Break Destinations

As long as academics have been a part of our lives,...

Camping in Iceland: Rules, Packing Tips and Everything You Need to Know

Get unlimited access to the world's best travel stories. subscribe now., privacy overview.

• Skip to primary navigation
• Skip to main content
• Skip to primary sidebar

Destinations

Experiences.

• Photography

Plan Your Trip

Sicily vs. Sardinia

October 28, 2021 by Robert Schrader Leave a Comment

Before I visited both islands, I had a pretty clear idea of where I’d land in the Sicily vs Sardinia debate. Or at least why I’d feel that way.

I knew Sardinia’s beaches would blow my mind, both because of pictures I’d seen, as well as testimony from a very good Sardinian friend of mine. On the other hand, sailing in Sardinia is a bit outside my price range, which left most of those beaches inaccessible to me. Indeed, since, I’m a traveler who thrives on cultural eclecticism—accessible, even effortless cultural eclecticism—I also knew Sicily would have the edge on that front.

And it does—Sicily this, is—as far as I’m concerned. However, the chasm between my enjoyment of these two most famous islands of Italy (at least for now) is much, much wider than I ever anticipated.

How I Came to Know Sicily and Sardinia

One way to explain Sardinia vs Sicily is to explain my journeys through both islands. I went to Sicily first, after about a week divided between the overrated Puglia region and Naples , a city that is criminally underrated. Starting in historical Siracusa and passing under Mt. Etna to scenic Taormina, I concluded my trip in eclectic Palermo and on the pristine beaches of Cefalú. It wasn’t a revelation, but it was refreshing.

Sardinia, on the other hand, fundamentally disappointed me. Cagliari was nothing to write home about; Olbia was nothing at all. The beaches I visited along the famous Costa Smeralda (and the slightly less famous Golfo di Orosei) weren’t terrible, but they weren’t as fantastic as they’d been reputed to be, and certainly not enough to lift my generally negative impression of the island.

Ways to Compare Sicily and Sardinia

Although Sardinia is more famous for beaches than Sicily, I found I prefer Sicilian beaches. This was most obvious when it came to Isola Bella off Taormina, but even Cefalú left me feeling warmer than Sardinian beaches like Cala Goloritze and Cala Brandinchi.

For me, food is an area where there simply is not comparison between Sicily vs Sardinia. Whether we’re walking about savory dishes like eggplant caponata or pesce di spada (swordfish) or desserts like canoli and granite , Sardinian food just can’t compete with what’s on offer in Sicily.

For most travelers, Sardinia is little more than the unspectacular capital of Cagliari and Olbia, which is a fake city constructed for beachgoers. With a few days in Sicily, meanwhile, you can string together Catania, Siracusa, Taormina and Palermo, and maybe add in excursions to Trapani and Agrigento too!

Transportation

When you take the Sicily vs Sardinia and compare it to mainland Italy, neither island scores well on the transportation front. Still, I found train and bus schedules were more robust and convenient in Sicily than Sardinia. In Sardinia, there is no public transportation along the coast at all; the inland rail line is slow and delay-prone.

Frankly, nowhere you stay in either Sicily or Sardinia is going to rock your world. With this being said, I did find there was more of a selection in Sicily, both for Airbnb apartments, as well as budget stays like Palermo’s Palazzo Natoli and more luxurious choices like Villa Carlotta in Taormina.

How Long Do You Need in Sicily and Sardinia?

If you have it, I’d recommend spending a week each in Sicily and Sardinia. I spent four days in each, and while I was able to make do with that, a week would’ve allowed me to accomplish more. In Sicily, I could’ve expanded my list of destinations; in Sardinia, I could’ve dug deeper into the various coastlines and found the beaches that are actually as amazing as people insist all of them are (they aren’t).

Generally speaking, I do wonder whether devoting longer to both these islands would’ve evened out my feelings RE: Sicily vs Sardinia. The reality is that spending 3-4 days in either Sardinia or Sicily isn’t sufficient, but the variety of destinations, experiences, culture and cuisine in Sicily makes the necessary lack of depth less impactful on the overall impression your trip leaves on you.

Other FAQ About Sicily and Sardinia

Which is better, sicily or sardinia.

In my opinion, Sicily is far superior to Sardinia. Destinations like Siracusa, Taormina and Cefalú offer a diversity an eclecticism you can’t find in Sardinia; Sicily’s beaches more than hold their own when compared to Sardinia’s, to say nothing of how singular a landform Mt. Etna is.

Are Sicily and Sardinia similar?

Sicily and Sardinia are as different from one another as any two places in Italy. From culture (Sicily is quintessentially Italian , while Sardinia seems more Catalan, if anything) to landscapes to cuisine, Sicily and Sardinia almost feel like two separate countries, never mind two different regions within one admittedly fragmented country.

Can you fly from Sardinia to Sicily?

You can easily fly from Sardinia to Sicily. For most travelers, this will involve a flight from Cagliari to either Palermo or Catania, depending on whether you want to travel clockwise or counterclockwise around Sicily once you get there.

The Bottom Line

Regarding the question of Sicily vs Sardinia, I come down heavily in favor of Sicily . In addition to offering a more interesting array of cities and towns (and a much greater quantity of them), Sicily holds its own against Sardinia in terms of beaches, which are supposed to be the latter’s strong suit. With this being said, I have to add a cliché caveat to this destination: It’s best for you to visit both islands on your own, lest you have to take my word for it. Which is not to say my word is not worth taking: No matter what your next trip to Italy ends up looking like, I encourage you to hire me as your Travel Coach . 

Subscribe to email updates!

Words, images and design ©2009-2024 Robert Schrader, All rights reserved. Read Privacy Policy or view sitemap .

• Sardinia , Sicily

Sardinia vs. Sicily

Table of Contents

In this article, we’ll dive into the details of these two fascinating destinations. Discover what sets them apart and makes them both worth visiting, whether it’s the culture, food, or beaches.

So, are you ready to explore Sardinia and Sicily? Let’s get started!

History & Culture

Both Sardinia and Sicily boast a rich and diverse history, with numerous civilizations leaving their mark on the islands. Let’s delve into the unique historical and cultural aspects of these two Mediterranean gems.

Sardinia, the second-largest island in the Mediterranean, has a distinct culture that sets it apart from mainland Italy.

Its history spans thousands of years, with the Nuragic civilization leaving behind mysterious stone towers, called nuraghi, scattered throughout the island. Over time, Sardinia was invaded and influenced by Phoenicians, Romans, Vandals, Byzantines, and more, all contributing to the island’s unique identity. Today, you can still find traces of these ancient civilizations in the island’s languages, customs, and traditions.

Sicily, on the other hand, has been a cultural melting pot for millennia. As the largest island in the Mediterranean, it has attracted numerous conquerors, including Greeks, Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, Normans, and Spanish, among others. This diverse range of influences has resulted in a complex and fascinating blend of cultures.

Sicily’s history is not only visible in its architectural treasures, like the stunning Greek temples and Roman mosaics, but also in its vibrant traditions, such as the famous puppet theater known as “Opera dei Pupi.”

When it comes to history and culture, both Sardinia and Sicily have their unique appeal. Sardinia’s ancient Nuragic civilization and its more isolated nature offer a different experience from Sicily’s multicultural richness. No matter which island you choose, you’ll be immersed in the captivating stories and customs of the Mediterranean’s past.

In summary, both Sardinia and Sicily offer a wealth of historical and cultural experiences that are sure to delight travelers. While Sardinia has a more distinct identity, thanks to its unique past and relative isolation, Sicily is a treasure trove of diverse influences that have created a rich and fascinating cultural tapestry. Whichever island you choose to visit, you’ll undoubtedly be enchanted by its captivating heritage.

Attractions and Activities

When it comes to attractions and activities, both Sardinia and Sicily have plenty to offer. Each island boasts an array of unique experiences that cater to different interests, from historical sites to outdoor adventures. Let’s compare what you can expect to find on each island.

In Sardinia, history buffs will be thrilled to explore the ancient nuraghi, the mysterious stone towers scattered across the island. One of the most famous is Su Nuraxi in Barumini, a UNESCO World Heritage site. You can also visit the ancient Roman city of Nora, with its stunning mosaics and well-preserved ruins.

If you’re an outdoor enthusiast, Sardinia offers exceptional hiking opportunities, such as the challenging Selvaggio Blu trek along the east coast or the more accessible Gorropu Gorge.

For a more leisurely experience, take a scenic train ride on the Trenino Verde, which winds through the heart of Sardinia’s stunning landscapes.

Sicily, on the other hand, offers a wealth of historical sites reflecting its diverse past. The Valley of the Temples in Agrigento, a UNESCO World Heritage site, is home to some of the best-preserved Greek temples outside of Greece. You can also explore the Roman Villa del Casale in Piazza Armerina, boasting exceptional mosaics that depict scenes from daily life in ancient Rome.

For those looking for an adrenaline rush, try hiking the volcanic Mount Etna, Europe’s highest and most active volcano. Alternatively, take a guided tour of the ancient catacombs in Syracuse or Palermo, where you can discover the early Christian and Jewish burial sites.

If you’re interested in exploring the local arts, both islands have a lot to offer. In Sardinia, you can attend traditional Sardinian music and dance performances or visit local artisans’ workshops to learn about their crafts. Sicily, with its vibrant arts scene, hosts various festivals throughout the year, such as the Taormina Film Festival or the Palermo International Puppet Theatre Festival.

In conclusion, both Sardinia and Sicily offer an array of attractions and activities that cater to a wide range of interests. While Sardinia’s unique nuraghi and outdoor adventures set it apart, Sicily’s diverse historical sites and vibrant arts scene make it equally appealing. No matter which island you choose, you’ll be treated to a memorable experience filled with unforgettable sights and activities.

The Mediterranean is known for its stunning beaches, and both Sardinia and Sicily offer an abundance of picturesque shorelines perfect for sunbathing, swimming, and water sports. Let’s explore the unique characteristics of each island’s beaches to help you decide which destination is right for your seaside getaway.

Sardinia is home to some of the most pristine beaches in the Mediterranean, with crystal-clear turquoise waters and fine white sand. One of the island’s most famous beaches is La Pelosa in Stintino, located in the northwestern corner of Sardinia. This beach is renowned for its calm, shallow waters, making it ideal for families with young children.

On the east coast, you’ll find the breathtaking beaches of Cala Gonone and Cala Goloritzé, which offer a more secluded and wild atmosphere, perfect for those seeking tranquility and unspoiled nature.

Sicily, meanwhile, boasts a diverse range of beaches, from sandy stretches to rocky coves. One of the most popular beaches on the island is Mondello, near the capital city of Palermo. This expansive, sandy beach offers numerous amenities, including beach clubs, bars, and restaurants.

If you’re looking for a more off-the-beaten-path experience, head to the stunning Scala dei Turchi on the southern coast, with its unique white limestone cliffs and turquoise waters. The Aeolian Islands, located off the northeastern coast of Sicily, also offer a variety of beaches and hidden coves, perfect for a more secluded beach escape.

In summary, both Sardinia and Sicily are blessed with an abundance of beautiful beaches, each with its unique charm. While Sardinia’s pristine shorelines and crystal-clear waters may be more appealing to some, Sicily’s diverse range of beach landscapes and nearby attractions offer an equally enticing experience. Whichever island you choose, you’re sure to find the perfect beach to suit your preferences.

Eating, Drinking & Nightlife

The Mediterranean is famous for its delicious cuisine, and both Sardinia and Sicily offer a wealth of gastronomic experiences, from traditional dishes to vibrant nightlife. Let’s compare the culinary delights and evening entertainment options that each island has to offer.

Sardinia’s cuisine is characterized by its use of locally sourced ingredients and traditional cooking methods. Expect to find dishes featuring fresh seafood, such as bottarga (cured fish roe) and fregola con arselle (a type of pasta with clams), as well as hearty meat dishes like porceddu (roast suckling pig). For dessert, try seadas , a sweet cheese-filled pastry drizzled with honey.

When it comes to nightlife, the island’s main hotspots are in the Costa Smeralda area, where you’ll find upscale bars and clubs. Alternatively, head to the cities of Cagliari and Alghero for a more laid-back atmosphere, with a mix of bars, pubs, and live music venues.

Sicily, on the other hand, is famous for its diverse culinary influences, which reflect the island’s rich history. Sample classic Sicilian dishes like arancini (rice balls stuffed with various fillings), pasta alla Norma (pasta with eggplant and ricotta), and the ever-popular cannoli, a crispy pastry filled with sweet ricotta cream. When it comes to drinks, don’t miss out on trying the local wines, such as Nero d’Avola or Marsala.

For nightlife, the cities of Palermo, Catania, and Taormina offer a variety of options, from trendy bars and clubs to more traditional taverns and wine bars. During the summer months, many coastal towns also host lively beach parties and outdoor events.

In conclusion, both Sardinia and Sicily provide a unique culinary and nightlife experience that will delight your taste buds and entertain you after the sun goes down. While Sardinia’s traditional dishes and upscale nightlife may appeal to some, Sicily’s diverse cuisine and varied evening entertainment options are sure to please those looking for a taste of the Mediterranean’s rich history and culture.

Whichever island you choose, you’ll undoubtedly enjoy the flavors and atmosphere that make the Mediterranean so captivating.

A vacation isn’t complete without a bit of shopping, and both Sardinia and Sicily offer a range of retail experiences, from local markets to luxury boutiques. Let’s compare the shopping options in these two Mediterranean islands to help you decide where to indulge in some retail therapy.

Sardinia is known for its unique, handmade crafts, including textiles, ceramics, and jewelry. For a truly authentic shopping experience, visit local markets like the San Benedetto market in Cagliari or the Alghero market, where you’ll find fresh produce, traditional cheeses, and artisanal products.

If you’re interested in high-end shopping, head to Porto Cervo in the Costa Smeralda area, where you’ll find designer boutiques and exclusive shops. For more mainstream shopping, larger cities like Cagliari and Sassari offer shopping centers and high-street stores.

Sicily, on the other hand, offers a mix of traditional crafts and modern shopping experiences. In cities like Palermo, Catania, and Taormina, you can explore bustling outdoor markets, such as Palermo’s Ballarò or Catania’s La Pescheria, where you’ll find everything from fresh produce to local crafts and antiques. Sicily is also known for its ceramics, which can be found in towns like Caltagirone and Santo Stefano di Camastra.

For those interested in luxury shopping, Taormina is home to designer boutiques and upscale stores, while cities like Palermo and Catania offer a variety of shopping centers and high-street shops.

In conclusion, both Sardinia and Sicily cater to different shopping preferences, with each island offering a unique retail experience. Sardinia’s traditional markets and upscale boutiques provide a contrast to Sicily’s diverse range of shopping options, which include both local crafts and high-end stores. Whichever island you choose, you’re sure to find a shopping experience that suits your tastes and budget.

Accommodation

When planning your vacation to either Sardinia or Sicily, finding the perfect accommodation is essential. Both islands offer a range of options to suit various budgets and preferences. Let’s compare the accommodation choices in these two Mediterranean destinations.

Sardinia has a diverse selection of lodging options, including luxury resorts, boutique hotels, and charming bed and breakfasts. The Costa Smeralda is known for its upscale hotels and exclusive resorts, perfect for those seeking a more luxurious experience. However, if you’re looking for a more budget-friendly option, there are plenty of guesthouses and holiday rentals throughout the island, particularly in the cities of Cagliari, Alghero, and Olbia.

Sicily, on the other hand, offers an equally diverse range of accommodations, from five-star hotels to cozy agriturismo (farm stay) options. In popular tourist destinations like Taormina, Palermo, and Catania, you’ll find a mix of luxury hotels, boutique properties, and budget-friendly hostels. For a more unique experience, consider staying in a traditional Sicilian villa or a charming bed and breakfast in one of the island’s smaller towns.

In summary, both Sardinia and Sicily offer a variety of accommodation options to suit different tastes and budgets. Whether you’re looking for luxury resorts, boutique hotels, or more affordable lodgings, you’re sure to find the perfect place to rest your head in either of these beautiful Mediterranean islands.

Family-Friendliness & Children’s Activities

Planning a family vacation is all about finding the right balance of activities and attractions that cater to both adults and children. Both Sardinia and Sicily offer a range of family-friendly options, ensuring a memorable and enjoyable experience for all ages. Let’s compare the family-friendliness and children’s activities available in these two Mediterranean destinations.

Sardinia is an excellent choice for families, thanks to its beautiful beaches with shallow waters, such as La Pelosa in Stintino or Cala Brandinchi in San Teodoro, which are perfect for young children to swim and play. The island also offers a variety of family-friendly attractions, such as the Sardinian Deer Park in Monte Ortobene or the Diverland water park in Quartu Sant’Elena.

Outdoor activities like horseback riding and guided nature walks are also popular with families, providing a fun and educational experience for kids and adults alike.

Sicily, too, is a fantastic destination for families, with its diverse landscapes and rich history providing ample opportunities for exploration and adventure. The island boasts numerous family-friendly beaches, such as Mondello near Palermo or San Vito Lo Capo on the northwest coast, where children can safely swim and play in the clear waters.

For a more educational experience, visit interactive museums like the Palermo Science Center or the Etnaland theme park near Catania, which features a range of attractions, including a water park, amusement rides, and a prehistoric park. Families can also explore the ancient ruins in the Valley of the Temples or the Roman Villa del Casale, providing an engaging and educational experience for all ages.

In conclusion, both Sardinia and Sicily offer an array of family-friendly attractions and activities that cater to children and adults alike. While Sardinia’s pristine beaches and outdoor adventures create a fun and safe environment for families, Sicily’s diverse landscapes and historical sites provide an equally appealing experience for those seeking a mix of leisure and learning.

Whichever island you choose, you can rest assured that your family vacation will be filled with unforgettable memories and experiences.

Getting There & Getting Around

Traveling to and exploring new destinations is an essential part of any vacation, and understanding the transportation options for Sardinia and Sicily will help you plan your trip more efficiently. Let’s compare the ease of getting to each island and the options for getting around once you’ve arrived.

To reach Sardinia, you can fly into one of its three main airports: Cagliari-Elmas, Olbia Costa Smeralda, or Alghero Fertilia. Several airlines offer direct flights from major European cities, as well as connecting flights from other international destinations. Alternatively, you can take a ferry from mainland Italy or France, with numerous routes available from cities like Genoa, Livorno, or Marseille.

Once on the island, renting a car is the most convenient way to explore, allowing you the freedom to visit remote beaches and attractions. Public transportation options include buses and a limited train network, but be prepared for less frequent service in rural areas.

Sicily is serviced by two main airports: Palermo Falcone-Borsellino and Catania-Fontanarossa, with direct flights from various European cities and connections from other international locations. Ferries also operate from mainland Italy, with routes from Naples, Genoa, and Civitavecchia.

Similar to Sardinia, renting a car is the best way to explore the island at your own pace, giving you the flexibility to discover hidden gems and off-the-beaten-path attractions.

Sicily has a more extensive train network than Sardinia, operated by Trenitalia, which connects major cities and towns. Buses are also available for intercity travel, but schedules can be less reliable in more remote areas.

In summary, both Sardinia and Sicily are easily accessible by air and sea, with multiple options for getting to each island. Once you’ve arrived, renting a car is the most convenient way to explore and make the most of your vacation. However, public transportation options are available for those who prefer not to drive, though they may be less reliable and more time-consuming, especially in rural areas.

Whichever island you choose, plan your transportation carefully to ensure a smooth and enjoyable travel experience.

The weather can greatly impact your vacation experience, so understanding the climate differences between Sardinia and Sicily is essential for planning your trip. Let’s compare the weather in these two Mediterranean islands to help you decide when and where to go.

Sardinia enjoys a Mediterranean climate, with hot, dry summers and mild, wet winters.

Summer temperatures typically range from 75°F to 90°F (24°C to 32°C), making it an ideal time to visit the island’s beautiful beaches. Spring and autumn are also pleasant, with temperatures ranging from 60°F to 75°F (16°C to 24°C), offering a more comfortable climate for outdoor activities and sightseeing.

Winter temperatures are generally mild, ranging from 50°F to 60°F (10°C to 16°C), but can be quite wet, particularly in the coastal areas.

Sicily, on the other hand, also features a Mediterranean climate but tends to be slightly warmer and drier than Sardinia.

Summers are hot, with temperatures ranging from 80°F to 95°F (27°C to 35°C), making it perfect for beachgoers and sun-seekers. Spring and autumn offer more moderate temperatures, between 65°F and 80°F (18°C to 27°C), ideal for exploring the island’s diverse landscapes and historical sites.

Winters in Sicily are generally mild, with temperatures between 55°F and 65°F (13°C to 18°C), and can be wetter in the coastal regions.

In conclusion, both Sardinia and Sicily offer a pleasant Mediterranean climate, with hot summers and mild winters. While Sicily is slightly warmer and drier overall, both islands provide an enjoyable climate for beach vacations, outdoor activities, and sightseeing.

When planning a vacation, safety is a crucial factor to consider. Both Sardinia and Sicily are popular Mediterranean destinations, and understanding the safety aspects of each island can help you enjoy a worry-free trip. Let’s compare the safety of Sardinia and Sicily.

Sardinia is generally considered a safe destination for tourists, with low crime rates and a relaxed atmosphere. Like anywhere, it’s essential to take basic precautions, such as keeping an eye on your belongings and avoiding poorly lit areas at night. However, overall, Sardinia offers a secure environment for travelers to explore and enjoy.

Sicily, too, is a relatively safe destination, with most tourists experiencing trouble-free visits. As with Sardinia, it’s essential to practice common sense and be aware of your surroundings, particularly in crowded areas where pickpocketing can occur. Generally, though, Sicily provides a safe and welcoming atmosphere for visitors.

In conclusion, both Sardinia and Sicily are generally safe destinations for travelers. As long as you take the usual precautions and stay aware of your surroundings, you can enjoy a secure and enjoyable vacation on either island.

Budget is often a significant factor when planning a vacation, so it’s essential to understand the cost differences between Sardinia and Sicily. Let’s compare the expenses you can expect to encounter in these two Mediterranean destinations.

Sardinia is generally considered a more expensive destination compared to Sicily. Accommodation costs tend to be higher, particularly in the upscale Costa Smeralda area. However, you can still find budget-friendly options in less touristy areas. A mid-range hotel in Sardinia can cost around €100 to €150 (approximately $110 to $165) per night.

Dining out in Sardinia can also be pricey, with a meal at a mid-range restaurant costing about €30 to €50 (approximately $33 to $55) per person.

Sicily, on the other hand, offers a more affordable travel experience. Accommodation costs are generally lower, with mid-range hotels averaging between €60 to €100 (approximately $66 to $110) per night.

When it comes to dining out, you can expect to pay around €20 to €40 (approximately $22 to $44) per person for a meal at a mid-range restaurant. Activities and attractions in Sicily also tend to be more budget-friendly than in Sardinia.

In summary, while Sardinia is known for its higher prices, particularly in popular tourist areas, Sicily offers a more budget-friendly experience for travelers. Regardless of which island you choose, it’s essential to plan and research your accommodations, activities, and dining options to ensure you make the most of your vacation budget.

Which Is Better – Sardinia or Sicily?

Choosing between Sardinia and Sicily for your Mediterranean vacation can be a challenging decision, as both islands offer unique experiences and charm. Let’s recap their differences and similarities to help you make the best choice for your trip.

In terms of history and culture, both islands boast rich pasts and fascinating traditions. Sardinia has a unique identity shaped by various civilizations, while Sicily presents an alluring mix of influences from its diverse conquerors. For attractions and activities, Sardinia offers stunning natural beauty, ancient sites, and outdoor pursuits, whereas Sicily provides a blend of historical sites, diverse landscapes, and cultural experiences.

When it comes to beaches, both islands feature beautiful coastlines with crystal-clear waters. Sardinia is known for its idyllic white-sand beaches, while Sicily boasts a mix of sandy shores and dramatic rocky coastlines.

For eating, drinking, and nightlife, both islands offer delicious cuisine, vibrant nightlife, and local wine, with Sardinia leaning towards a more upscale experience and Sicily presenting a more authentic, down-to-earth atmosphere.

Shopping in Sardinia and Sicily varies, with Sardinia offering high-end boutiques in popular tourist areas and Sicily providing more traditional markets and local artisan shops. Accommodation options in both destinations range from luxury resorts to budget-friendly stays, with Sardinia generally being more expensive.

Family-friendliness and children’s activities are abundant on both islands, ensuring fun and memorable experiences for travelers of all ages.

In terms of getting there and getting around, both islands are easily accessible by air and sea, with multiple transportation options available. Renting a car is the most convenient way to explore either island, while public transportation options exist for those who prefer not to drive.

When comparing the weather, both Sardinia and Sicily offer pleasant Mediterranean climates, with Sicily being slightly warmer and drier overall. Safety-wise, both destinations are generally safe for travelers, as long as basic precautions are taken. Lastly, in terms of cost, Sardinia is typically more expensive than Sicily, but both islands can cater to various budgets.

In conclusion, choosing between Sardinia and Sicily ultimately depends on your preferences and priorities.

If you’re looking for a more luxurious experience, pristine white-sand beaches, and unique local culture, Sardinia may be the perfect choice. On the other hand, if you’re seeking a more budget-friendly vacation with diverse historical and cultural attractions, a mix of beach styles, and a vibrant local atmosphere, Sicily could be the ideal destination for you.

Whichever island you decide to visit, you’re sure to create unforgettable memories in these enchanting Mediterranean paradises.

About  | Contact  | Privacy Policy

Copyright © Loco Media

Accessibility Links

Sardinia v Sicily: which is better?

The mediterranean’s two largest islands compete on food, bars, hotels, culture – and beaches, of course.

T hey’re the two largest islands in the Mediterranean, each packing a punch with history, culture, food, and beaches galore. Each also comes with lashings of dolce vita — and yet Sicily and Sardinia couldn’t be more different. A cultural gumbo for thousands of years, with conquerors passing through one after the other, Sicily tells its story through its florid architecture and its food, which blends sweet and savoury unlike anywhere else in Italy. Those foreigners also made it to Sardinia, yet their touch was lighter. This is still a wild island with pristine beaches and a mountainous hinterland, plus remnants of the mysterious prehistoric Nuragic culture at every turn. You can’t go wrong with either, of course, but which should you choose? It all depends what kind of break you’re after.

Main photo: jumping into the sea in the Maddalena archipelago in Sardinia (Getty Images) ; Savoca in Sicily (Alamy)

Winner Sardinia

When it comes to coastline, few places can square up to Sardinia . In the north lies glitzy Costa Smeralda, as well as wild islands including the Maddalena archipelago, and a sand-wrapped peninsula around Stintino. The east, meanwhile, is dotted with pristine cale — tiny coves chomping away at the coastline. They normally require either a scramble down the cliff or an arrival by boat, making them relatively unspoilt. On the south, there are sandy beaches around resorts such as Chia and Nora, while the wild west has some beautiful stretches, particularly around Oristano — try Is Arutas, a beach of polished quartz pebbles.

Sicily also has gorgeous beaches, though the coastline is much more built up and some of the most atmospheric are town beaches, from Scopello and Cefalu to Mondello and Capo Peloro, a glorious swathe of sand melting into the Strait of Messina. The Scala dei Turchi, near Agrigento, is a dramatic white cliff shaved into natural layers that’s perfect for sunbathing and surrounded by sand.

Advertisement

Don’t forget the islands — on the Egadi archipelago, off the west coast, Favignana is a good bet, while on the Aeolian islands, between Sicily and Calabria, the swarthy black-sand beaches on volcanic Stromboli are unmissable. Willing to go further? Lampedusa — closer to Tunisia than Sicily — has one of Italy ’s loveliest sandy beaches, the Spiaggia dei Conigli.

Winner Sicily

Few Italian regions can match Sicily’s energy — and that energy means great nightlife. On weekends in Palermo , hordes spill out onto the street, clutching their drinks outside the bars; in Catania, the scene takes place around the Quadrato d’Oro (Golden Square), between Piazzas Universita, Teatro Massimo and del Duomo. There’s also a strong cocktail scene across the island, from bars Close and Roseaelia in Palermo to Catania’s speakeasy-style Bohème and Ortigia’s Boats, which names cocktails after luminaries from Frida Kahlo to Greta Thunberg.

In Sardinia, the Costa Smeralda and Cagliari top and tail the island with two great cocktail scenes. In Cagliari, try the old-school American Bar Biffi and Caffé Libarium Nostrum, located on the panoramic city ramparts. The Costa Smeralda, meanwhile, is the place for glitzy drinks with a view. Daytime drinkers will love its beach clubs — try Phi Beach and Nikki Beach — while at night, barhop along the rooftop lounges, such as Upper Palau and Le Terrazze Ritual.

Restaurants

Even for Italy, Sicily’s food scene punches above its weight. Its unique dishes are thanks to the waves of cultures that have colonised, passed through or migrated to the island — particularly Arabs, who finessed Sicily’s classic agrodolce (bittersweet) flavour, which you’ll find in signature dishes from caponata (aubergines, tomatoes, olives and more in a sweet, vinegary sauce) to polpettine in agrodolce (meatballs). Couscous is big here — more North African influence — and Sicily also has world-class street food, from arancini (or arancine in Palermo) and panelle (chickpea fritters) to pani ca meusa, rolls filled with deep-fried offal and topped with grated cheese — better than it sounds. Sicily’s restaurant scene ranges from those street-food stalls to high end — there are 19 Michelin-starred restaurants across the island, including the creative Duomo in Ragusa, and Palermo’s Mec, which puts a contemporary spin on traditional Sicilian flavours. You’ll also find plenty of regular restaurants and trattorie, but look out for simpler options too — one of our favourite places on the island is Dai Pennisi in Linguaglossa, a butcher’s shop with sit-down tables for eating on the spot, run by the Pennisi family who own the Michelin-starred Shalai.

Sardinia is home to one of the world’s Blue Zones — areas of remarkable longevity — and when you understand the diet, you begin to grasp why. Freshness is key here, as are vegetables, and honey is used instead of sugar. While today you’ll find fish on the menu, traditional Sardinian food comes from the inland — so as well as meat you’ll find incredible cheese (seada, the unofficial regional dessert, is a fried pasta pocket stuffed with fresh pecorino and honey), products such as artichokes and saffron, and local pasta, from fregola to the potato, garlic, mint and cheese-stuffed culurgiones. This is also an island of exceptional bread — don’t miss the crispy, tissue-thin pane carasau. Sardinia’s restaurant scene is at its fanciest in the Costa Smeralda — half the six Michelin-starred restaurants on the island are here (we like Il Fuoco Sacro, hoisted high above the coast in the Petra Segreta resort). Again, you’ll also find a wealth of styles across the island, with Spanish-influenced dishes in Alghero and Sardinian classics in Cagliari (try Del Corsaro, third-generation and family-run, or La Locanda dei Buoni e Cattivi, a non-profit training marginalised youngsters, which has been recognised by the Slow Food movement). Prices are generally higher than Sicily but this is a place where everything is good quality — even the beachside tourist traps in Alghero do excellent food.

You’re onto a winner with the hotels of the Costa Smeralda. Sardinia’s jet-set status means it has five-star hotels coming out of its ears, from Hotel Cala di Volpe in the north to Forte Village in the south. They’re classic beach resorts, but stray inland and you’ll find unique properties, such as Su Gologone, a mountain-wrapped hotel that blends local traditions with high-design style (and a clientele to match), and Villa Asfodeli, an albergo diffuso (scattered hotel) on the west coast, in Tresnuraghes village.

• Best hotels in Sardinia

Its swaggering past means that Sicily does a fine line in grande dame hotels, from Palermo’s Villa Igiea to San Domenico Palace, the Four Seasons hotel in Taormina that was the setting for The White Lotus . The island’s food obsession means there are gastro hotels galore — in the Etna wine region we love organic estate Monaci delle Terre Nere, and Shalai, a small design-centric hotel with a Michelin-starred restaurant. In the interior, meanwhile, there’s Tenuta Regaleali, a winery with rooms in the hills above the famous Anna Tasca Lanza cooking school. The island is studded with equally lovely, but less ritzy options, from Antico Feudo San Giorgio, an upmarket agriturismo in Tuscany-style rolling hills, to Sopra Moltivolti, a swish B&B run by Moltivolti, a non-profit supporting refugees and migrants, with a superb restaurant below the rooms.

• Best hotels in Sicily

Things to do

It’s the sheer variety that makes Sicily unbeatable. This cultural melting pot has Greek temples and towns, mosques-turned-churches, Byzantine mosaics, and Arab and Norman architecture all swirled together. There are sandy beaches, Tuscany-style rolling hills, hikeable mountains, national parks and islands that range from pristine paradises to active volcanoes. Most visitors stick to the coast, which means the interior is beautifully unspoilt. The Heart of Sicily project aims to develop sustainable inland tourism.

Sardinia’s beaches are so dazzling that many people don’t stray beyond the sand — but they’re missing one of the Med’s most fascinating islands. Stonehenge pales in comparison to the prehistoric sites here, from nuraghi (tower-topped circular settlements — Su Nuraxi is the finest) and stone circles to monumental Domus de Janas tombs and vast saucer-eyed statues, the Giganti di Mont’e Prama on display in Cabras. The tiny villages in its mountainous interior have strong traditions, from the political murals of Orgosolo to the world-class nougat of Tonara. Throw in Phoenician settlements, historic Cagliari and Alghero, plus the 20th-century industrial sites of the west coast, and you have thousands of years of history at your fingertips.

• Best things to do in Sardinia • Best things to do in Sicily

Sign up for the Times Travel Newsletter here .

Related articles

Sardinia vs. Sicily: Which Mediterranean Gem is Right for Your Next Vacation?

Choosing between sardinia and sicily: unraveling th allure of italy's premier islands.

Sardinia and Sicily shine as jewels of the Mediterranean, each boasting its distinct charm. Sardinia, the second-largest island, is renowned for its turquoise waters, beautiful beaches like Cala Brandinchi, and a history of tradition. On the flip side, Sicily, the largest island, dazzles with its diverse cultural heritage, from Greek history to Baroque beauty and the majestic Mount Etna .

Are you drawn to the crystal-clear waters of Sardinia’s coastal towns or the historical sites of Sicily’s beautiful cities? Whether it’s the allure of Sicilian cuisine, the serenity of pristine beaches, or the call of vibrant beach parties, our exploration will guide you in choosing the perfect Italian island for your next unforgettable vacation.

Geography & Landscape:

Sardinia, a jewel in the heart of the Mediterranean, presents a unique blend of geography that’s both captivating and diverse. Dominated by rugged mountains that stretch across its terrain, Sardinia’s landscape is a mesmerizing mix of high peaks and deep valleys. Its most celebrated feature is its stunning coastline. With renowned beaches like Spiaggia della Pelosa and Cala Luna, the island offers diverse sandy retreats, from white sand beaches to secluded coves, all embraced by the island’s signature turquoise waters.

Sicily is the Mediterranean’s largest island and one of its most geographically diverse. The island boasts a tapestry of landscapes, from its rolling hills carpeted with olive groves and vineyards to its extensive coastline dotted with gorgeous beaches and picturesque towns.

However, standing tall and ever-present is Mt. Etna, Europe’s highest and most active volcano, casting its shadow over the eastern part of the island. This volcanic giant, along with the Aeolian and other volcanic islands, adds a fiery twist to Sicily’s geography, juxtaposing its tranquil beach destinations and historical landmarks.

Culture & History:

Sardinia’s history is both deep and unique, with its roots tracing back to the mysterious Nuragic civilization . Scattered across the island, the thousands of archaeological sites , including the iconic Nuragic towers and settlements, stand a testament to this Bronze Age civilization that has left an indelible mark on Sardinia’s cultural fabric.

Modern-day Sardinia is also alive with vibrant festivals and traditions. Events such as the Cavalcade Sarda and the Mamuthones festival bring the streets to life with color, dance, and music. Adding to its distinctiveness is the Sardinian language or Sardo . While Italian is widely spoken, Sardo remains a proud emblem of the island’s unique identity, echoing its storied past and strong tradition.

Sicily, often described as a crossroads of civilizations, has a rich history that has seen the rise and fall of many empires. From the architectural wonders left behind by the Greeks to the ornate artistry of the Normans, every corner of the island whispers tales of its diverse past. This blend of cultures over the millennia has given birth to various Sicilian festivals, each celebrating the island’s multifaceted heritage.

The island’s culinary traditions, featuring famous dishes like Arancini and Cannoli , reflect this cultural amalgamation. Whether it’s the echoes of Greek history, the Baroque beauty of the 17th and 18th centuries, or the colorful mosaic of influences from Africa, the Middle East, and mainland Italy, Sicily is a testament to the harmonious blend of cultures that have shaped its identity.

Cuisine & Gastronomy:

Sardinian cuisine reflects the island’s rich history, diverse landscape, and the sea surrounding it. A must-try is Malloreddus , a gnocchi often served with a hearty sausage sauce. For meat lovers, Porceddu , or roasted suckling pig, is a traditional delight that tantalizes the taste buds with its crispy skin and succulent meat. Ending a meal without sampling Seadas , a sweet pastry filled with cheese and drizzled with honey, would be a culinary oversight. Beyond these dishes, Sardinia boasts an array of unique beverages.

The island’s wines, especially the robust red Cannonau and the crisp white Vermentino, complement its delicious food . Not to forget, the local spirit, Mirto , made from myrtle berries, offers a delightful end to any Sardinian feast.

In Sicily, every meal is a journey through its rich history and the influences of the many cultures that have called the island home. Starting with the savory, Arancini , deep-fried rice balls filled with various ingredients make for a popular snack or starter. The island’s love for sweets is evident in the world-famous Cannoli , crispy pastry tubes filled with sweet ricotta cheese.

Another staple in Sicilian cuisine is Caponata , a flavorful aubergine dish that blends sweet and sour tastes to perfection. But the gastronomic tour continues beyond just food. Sicily’s fertile soils produce some of Italy’s finest wines, including the robust Nero d’Avola and the sweet Marsala.

Pair these with local desserts like Cassata or almond pastries, and you have a feast fit for the gods, showcasing the true essence of Sicilian cuisine .

Attractions & Activities:

Sardinia’s Costa Smeralda is an absolute paradise for those seeking sun, sea, and sand. With its stunning beaches and azure waters, it remains one of the Mediterranean’s premier beach destinations. But beyond the coast, adventure beckons.

The Gennargentu National Park offers nature enthusiasts an array of activities, from hiking amidst its rugged terrains to bird-watching and discovering the island’s diverse flora and fauna. Sardinia’s charm isn’t limited to its natural wonders. Towns like San Teodoro and coastal cities, including Alghero and Cagliari , showcase the island’s vibrant culture, rich history, and the warm hospitality of its people.

History enthusiasts flock to Sicily to explore its numerous historic sites . The Valley of the Temples in Agrigento is a testament to the island’s Greek heritage. At the same time, the ancient city of Syracuse reveals layers of civilizations that have shaped Sicily over the millennia. For nature lovers, Mt. Etna isn’t just a scenic backdrop.

Hiking on this active volcano offers breathtaking views and an adrenaline rush. Beyond these iconic landmarks, Sicily is dotted with hidden gems . From the beautiful coastal towns of Taormina and Cefalù to interior wonders like the hilltop town of Enna , Sicily promises a blend of culture, beauty, and unforgettable experiences for every traveler.

Accessibility & Infrastructure:

Navigating Sardinia is both convenient and straightforward. The island is well-connected with several airports, with Cagliari Elmas Airport , Olbia Costa Smeralda Airport , and Alghero Fertilia Airport being the major gateways. These airports frequently host flights from major European cities, making Sardinia easily accessible for international travelers. In addition, Sardinia’s major ports, such as Olbia and Porto Torres , facilitate ferry connections to mainland Italy and other Mediterranean destinations.

Once on the island, the road infrastructure is commendable, with a network of well-maintained highways and regional roads. While public transport is available, renting a car from a reputable company offers the most flexibility to explore the island’s secluded coves and picturesque towns.

Sicily, the largest island in the Mediterranean, boasts an extensive infrastructure to cater to its visitors. The major airports include Catania-Fontanarossa and Palermo Falcone-Borsellino Airport , ensuring excellent connectivity to European and international destinations. Additionally, the ports of Palermo and Messina serve as pivotal points for ferries linking Sicily with the Italian mainland and other islands.

As for intra-island transportation, Sicily offers a wide range of options. From its efficient rail system, connecting major cities to the vast network of buses serving even the remotest villages, moving around is a breeze. However, considering car rentals or joining local tours can provide a richer, more immersive experience for those looking to delve deeper into the island’s heart.

Practical Information for Travelers:

For budget-conscious travelers, it’s essential to know that Sardinia, especially in areas like the Costa Smeralda, can sometimes be perceived as an expensive destination, especially during the peak summer months. However, with a wider range of options outside the main tourist hotspots, one can have a memorable yet budget-friendly experience.

Average temperatures during the summer season in Sardinia are warm and inviting, with dry summers being the norm. As for accommodation, from luxury resorts in North Sardinia to quaint B&Bs in hilltop towns like Tempio Pausania, there’s something for every traveler. If beach time is a priority, consider staying close to famous sandy stretches like Spiaggia del Principe or Cala Brandinchi for unforgettable experiences.

Compared to Sardinia, Sicily often emerges as a more affordable option for many. That said, popular destinations like Taormina can fetch higher prices, especially during the sunny summers. Sicily’s average temperatures are comfortable, with the summer months being hot but pleasant, thanks to the coastal breeze. Those looking to immerse themselves in the island’s rich culture and cultural heritage might consider visiting during spring or fall for a mix of pleasant temperatures and fewer crowds.

Accommodation in Sicily provides a vast range, from luxurious hotels overlooking crystal-clear waters to budget stays in the heart of its beautiful cities. For those keen on exploring historic landmarks , staying in the historic center of major cities or close to archaeological sites like the Valley of the Temples or Villa Romana del Casale can provide both convenience and a rich dose of the island’s fascinating history.

Conclusion:

The Mediterranean gems of Sardinia and Sicily each weave a unique tapestry of experiences that beckon travelers from around the world. With its pristine beaches like Costa Smeralda and rugged landscapes, Sardinia promises a blend of natural beauty and cultural immersion. Whether it’s savoring the unique flavors of Sardinian cuisine or exploring the remnants of the Nuragic civilization, Sardinia is a destination that resonates with those in search of both relaxation and adventure.

On the other hand, Sicily, the largest island in the Mediterranean, is a treasure trove of historical sites , stunning landscapes, and culinary traditions that span millennia. From the fiery peaks of Mount Etna to the Baroque beauty of its cities and the tranquil allure of its turquoise waters , Sicily offers a diverse palette of experiences that cater to a wide range of tastes.

Ultimately, choosing between Sardinia and Sicily is a delightful dilemma. Both islands, rich in cultural heritage and with natural wonders, promise unforgettable experiences. As you ponder your next vacation destination, consider what ignites your passion, stirs your soul, and aligns with your travel aspirations. Whether it’s the serene shores of Sardinia or the historic heartbeats of Sicily, rest assured both islands promise memories that will last a lifetime. Safe travels, and may your journey be as enriching as the destination!

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

• Media kit | Following The Rivera
• Following the Rivera Privacy Policy
• Following the Rivera Disclaimer

Sardinia or Sicily: which island should you visit?

Last updated on March 25th, 2024.

When planning a vacation to Italy, the hardest part can be deciding where you want to go.

As a general rule of thumb, I always advise first-time visitors to pick one point of interest. This could be visiting one, or two, of the major architectural cities in Italy or escaping to an idyllic Italian island.

In this post, I’ll be guiding you through the latter, asking the question: should you visit Sardinia or Sicily?

I want to stress that this isn’t a ‘which is better’ kind of post. Both Sardinia and Sicily are beautiful in their own right, and this helpful comparison will hopefully help you to decide.

Both destinations are ideal Italy bucket list material and wholly worth considering. Use this post to help plan your trip to Italy .

Should you visit Sardinia or Sicily?

Mediterranean goliaths.

Sicily holds the title as the largest island not just in Italy, but also in the Mediterranean Sea. Measuring 25,711sq km, it’s an island I know well as we return to our home here every summer.

An important thing to note are the islands’ respective population sizes. Sicily is home to approximately 5 million people (est. 2021) compared to around 1.6 million (est. 2021) in Sardinia. This will be important to remember for later.

Situated north of Sicily is the island of Sardinia. Compared to Sicily, Sardinia is smaller measuring 24,100 sq km. To the north of Sardinia is Corsica, the fourth largest island in the region.

The second largest island after Sicily, many Italians flock to Sardinia for their summer vacation. A destination we fell in love with on our Sardinia road trip , it surprised us (in a very good way).

With a distance of 524km (326m) between them, these 2 goliath islands offer tons of travel potential. The only question is, which should you visit: Sardinia or Sicily?

Best beaches: Sardinia or Sicily?

Ask the majority of Italians which island has the best beaches of the two, and they’ll likely say Sardinia.

And, having traveled around both islands, I’ve to agree 100%. While I’m not saying that Sicily doesn’t have beautiful beaches, the dozen or more we saw in Sardinia were superior.

I’d say that 90% of the beaches we visited in Sardinia — and passed in the car — were sandy. Frankly speaking, they were better maintained and cleaner too.

I think one of the biggest reasons behind this is the difference in population size. With fewer people living in Sardinia, there are simply not as many people compared to Sicily to frequent its beaches.

The result? Plenty of sandy, and pristine, beaches in Sardinia, with an abundance of space to escape the masses.

Sand vs stone

Sicily, in comparison, does have sandy beaches, but I’ve also come across plenty of stony beaches too. While it doesn’t take away from being a nice beach, my personal preference leans towards a sandy landscape.

Should your preferences follow mine, here are several sandy beaches in Sicily you may want to consider visiting.

• The beaches surrounding Isola delle Correnti
• Scala dei Turchi (Turkish steps)
• La Plage SantoMar ( near Marzamemi )
• San Vito Lo Capo, Trapani
• Spiaggia di Màcari, Trapani
• Spiaggia di San Giuliano, Trapani
• Spiaggia di Lido Burrone, Favignana

In Sardinia, the list of sandy, and simply incredible beaches could easily take up an entire page. Instead, I’ll list some of my favorites. They include:

• Any of the beaches leading to, and surrounding Villasimius
• Dune di Piscinas, Arbus
• the beaches of La Maddalena
• The beaches around Porto Pino
• Spiaggia de La Sciumara
• Spiaggia di Cala di Trana
• Spiaggia di Porto Pollo
• Cala Napoletana
• Spiaggia Testa del Polpo

Map of Sardinia

Best island for history and architecture: Sardinia or Sicily?

When deciding between Sardinia or Sicily as a destination for history and architecture, Sicily wins hands down.

Sicily’s rich history dates as far back to the time of the Ancient Greeks. Given its geographical location, many groups subsequently arrived in Sicily and influenced and shaped the island during their rule.

These groups included the Romans, Phoenicians, Byzantine Greeks, Normans and Arabs to name but a few.

Consequently, Sicily has dozens of beautiful places to explore and with a colorful history to discover.

Today, it’s possible to see many historical monuments and sites left behind from many of these eras. One of the most famous is Valle dei Templi (Valley of the Temples) located in Agrigento. Covering 1,300 hectares, the archaeological site is home to striking examples of Ancient Greek art and architecture.

The largest of its kind in the world, Valle dei Templi is a site you’ll never forget.

Sicilian heavyweights

What I love about being in Sicily is that you don’t need to go far to find ancient architectural sights. Many of the bigger cities have so much to see, and make for a perfect weekend break.

The capital city of Palermo is teeming with incredible sights and holds an electric energy that’s unique to the city. On the east side of Sicily is Catania, a city whose historic center you can easily see in one day .

One of the island’s most notable characteristics is its Sicilian Baroque architecture . From churches to palazzos, the following cities will take you on your very own visual history lesson.

• Ragusa and Modica
• Palazzolo Acreide

Pre-historic Sardinia

Unlike Sicily, I wouldn’t recommend visiting Sardinia for its architectural sites. Many of its cities, like Cagliari, Oristano and Alghero, though charming, are quite ‘new’ by comparison. To clarify, many of the sights we came across were built in the 20th century.

But, one feature in Sardinia that provides a fascinating insight into its ancient past are its nuraghe ruins . Many of these pre-historic stone settlements are still intact and visible around central and northern Sardinia. Some of the most prominent nuraghe sites include:

• Complesso nuragico di Palmavera, Alghero
• Nuraghe Crabioni, Sassari
• Nuraghe Santu Antine, Torralba
• Complesso nuragico e Nurraghe di Noddule, Nuoro

Weather: Sardinia or Sicily?

When talking about the weather in Sardinia or Sicily, both islands are more or less the same. Whether you plan on visiting Sicily or Sardinia in April, May, June or October, you can expect similar temperatures.

Personally, I find April in Sicily to still be a little on the fresh side. Average temperatures can range from 18°C (64°F) to 21°C (70°F), and you should prepare for any eventuality of rain.

Sardinia temperatures in April are similar with average high temperatures of 20°C (67°F) and average lows of 10°C (49°F).

Perfect time to visit Sicily or Sardinia

Personally, I love visiting Sicily in May . From mid- to late May, daily average temperatures can reach a maximum of 25°C (77°F). While it may be too cool to hit the beach, it’s ideal for exploring the cities or for hiking Etna .

May in Sardinia is also a delightful time to visit. Maximum daytime temperatures hover around 22°C (72°F) and rainfall averages are around 9 days.

June and October are equally both good times to visit Sardinia or Sicily. During these months, you can expect plenty of sunny, dry weather and fewer visitors around.

Food culture: Sardinia or Sicily?

As an avid foodie, this isn’t an easy question to answer. But, if pressed, I’d say that Sicily has a more varied food culture, which makes it better (in my book).

From breakfast to dinner

In Sicily, the richness of the island’s food culture is apparent from the moment you wake up. A traditional Sicilian breakfast consists of a granita Siciliana and brioche roll . Light, it isn’t, but I guarantee you won’t be hungry for hours after eating one.

Lunch in Sicily is always a flavorful affair. Whether we dine on vegetarian dishes like caponata or melanzane ripiene (stuffed eggplants) or fish-based dishes, we always eat well.

Delicious, but less varied

Dining in Sardinia was a delicious, though noticeably different experience.

Sicilian cuisine draws on many cultural influences, as well as from its surroundings, something which is reflected in the food. To give you an example, several restaurants in the city of Mazara del Vallo serve typical Arabic/ northern African dishes like couscous .

Sardinia, with a different history and fewer people, also have fewer typical dishes and less variety. Before visiting Sardinia, we were told by many not to expect many, or any, good fish restaurants.

But, during our travels, we found the contrary. Nearly all of the restaurants we dined at offered fish and seafood and we always left satisfied.

Some of Sardinia’s most famous dishes include:

• Culurgiones (stuffed pasta dumplings)
• Fregola pasta (ball shaped semolina pasta)
• Maialino (wood roasted young pork)
• Agnello coi carciofi (lamb with artichokes)

Again, I want to stress that we ate well in Sardinia, but I personally prefer Sicilian food. The variety, flavors, vegetables, fish and meat make up one delicious package .

Cost: Sardinia or Sicily

The last topic I want to discuss when deciding on Sardinia or Sicily is the cost.

Like many destinations, the time of year you visit can be a big factor. Visit in July or August and expect to pay more. Sardinia typically has a reputation for being an expensive destination, especially if you visit the north.

However, it’s possible to plan a budget trip to Sardinia , and you won’t return home feeling totally broke. The south of Sardinia is wilder, less polished but is beautiful and really affordable.

Sardinia’s main attractions, its beaches, are all free (unless you want to pay for a lounge chair and umbrella). The bulk of our costs went towards accommodation and gas for the car.

Purse-friendly Sicily

Aside from visiting in August, prices in Sicily can be very reasonable. Touristy destinations like Taormina or Cefalu will be more expensive than visiting a smaller, and lesser known, town.

Another thing to know about Sicily is that portion sizes are generous. I never finish my meals here and always leave satisfied. So, if you like getting value for money, I highly recommend coming to Sicily.

Which island do you want to visit?

Comparison done, I hope I’ve provided some useful information on whether to visit Sardinia or Sicily. Both make an ideal vacation destination and I’m certain you’ll enjoy yourself whichever island you choose.

Which island would you like to visit, Sardinia or Sicily? Let me know in the comments below.

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, which means I may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that I’ve recommended. Thank you for your support.

Like this post? Pin it!

You Might Also Like

• A south Sardinia road trip itinerary
• A road trip from Sicily to Perugia
• How to plan a budget trip to Sardinia

LET'S CONNECT

Get your free Sicily eBook when you sign up today. Plus regular practical and helpful Italy travel guides and resources straight to your inbox.

Grazie mille! Welcome to the Italy travel tribe

Welcome to my site. I'm Lisa, an Italy-based travel and lifestyle blogger behind Following the Rivera. Find out more about me and my story.

48 thoughts on “ Sardinia or Sicily: which island should you visit? ”

Sicily and Sardinia! Can I just see them both please! Both are on my list to visit. They both are so beautiful and share a lot of similarities. The beaches, the crystal clear water, Mediterranean food…. maybe it comes down to cost. With Sicily as you are suggesting might be a bit more budget friendly.

The south of Sardinia is very affordable than the north and with wilder landscapes. But, both are definitely worth seeing 🙂

I’d love to visit both, but I guess I’d choose Sicily if I had to pick one. There’s something about it that appeals to me very much.

You definitely have a lot to see and plenty of history to discover

A very nicely written comparable post on Sicily and Sardinia as prospective destinations for vacation. I think both the islands are extremely beautiful with pros and cons for each. And it’s nice to know that both have sandy and Stony beaches and the best time to visit. The turquoise waters lining the crystalline beaches are awesome and so is the authentic briche roll and granite Siciliana. I would love to visit both Sardinia and Sicily.

Thank you so much Puloma! They are both beautiful and different in their own way

While I would love to go to both, Sicily is my first choice. I am dying to see the Greek ruins, French cathedrals, and Arab mosques. Plus there is the bonus of visiting a volcano.

Very true! And you won’t be disappointed in visiting 🙂

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed .

Pin It on Pinterest

• 6 Reasons You Should Visit...

Sicily v Sardinia: Which Italian Island Should You Visit?

The two largest islands in Italy have an abundance of spectacular scenery, striking architecture and culinary delights – each with a distinct character. To help you decide which one to visit, here’s a flavour of what Sicily and Sardinia have to offer.

Want to visit Sicily? Book Culture Trip’s 10-day adventure , where you’ll be able to eat local cuisine, bounce around Mount Etna in a 4×4 and be guided through the ancient towns of Noto, Ragusa and Modica by our local insider.

Delicious food

Italian cuisine varies greatly between regions, and Sicily’s has been heavily shaped by Arabic, Greek, French and Spanish influences over the years. You’ll still find typical pizza and pasta dishes – particularly in Palermo and Catania – but why not sample some delicious Sicilian delicacies for a more authentic experience?

Arancini (deep-fried stuffed rice balls) and cannoli (tube-shaped pastries filled with sweet ricotta) are ubiquitous across the island. If you’re feeling more adventurous, try a p ane con la milza (pork spleen sandwich) before cleansing the palate with a scoop of granita (a semi-frozen dessert made with ice, sugar and fruit).

Although not quite as expansive, Sardinian cuisine features numerous specialities you’re unlikely to find anywhere else in Italy. Culurgiones (pasta stuffed with creamy potato, fresh mint and pecorino cheese) and s paghetti ai ricci di mare (sea urchin spaghetti) are two traditional favourites.

Diverse landscapes

If pristine sandy beaches are what you’re looking for, Sardinia certainly won’t disappoint. There’s a vast array to choose from around the 1,849km (1,148mi) coastline – with Cala Goloritzé, Porto Istana, Cala Brandinchi and Spiaggia del Principe among the highlights. Swim in calm, clear waters or lie back and catch some rays – it’s one of the prime spots in Europe to do so. Sicily has no shortage either, with many of its beaches characterised by pebbles and craggy rock formations – as well as a handful of sandier shores more suitable for sunbathing, such as San Vito Lo Capo and Mondello.

Mount Etna, the tallest active volcano in Europe at around 10,826ft (3300m), dominates the northeastern skyline of Sicily and offers an ideal vantage point for panoramic views. Follow one of the easily accessible walking trails or take the cable car for a more relaxing route up the slopes. On the northwest coast, the Zingaro Nature Reserve contains several excellent hiking routes if you want to experience a totally contrasting side to the natural landscapes of Sicily. Hikers are also spoilt for choice in Sardinia, with coastal, mountain and forest trails aplenty. Neptune’s Grotto – an awe-inspiring stalactite cave – is well worth exploring, too.

Cultural heritage

Sicily’s complex history of invasion and foreign rule is reflected in the varied architectural styles of the towns and cities. You can admire the intriguing blend of Norman, Arab, gothic and neoclassical influences at Palermo Cathedral, which – together with the Cathedrals of Cefalù and Monreale – form part of a Unesco World Heritage list of religious and civic landmarks. The late renaissance-style Teatro Massimo – the largest opera house in Europe – is another impressive sight, both inside and out.

For one of the most extensive and best-preserved sites of ancient Greek temples and monuments in the world, take a trip to the Valley of the Temples – where the Temple of Concordia bears a powerful resemblance to the Parthenon of Athens. Syracuse, a picturesque city on the southeastern coast, is similarly steeped in Greek and Roman culture.

Vibrant towns and cities

From the grand religious buildings and rambunctious food markets of Palermo in the north to the baroque piazzas and exuberant nightlife of Catania in the east, the urban hubs of Sicily are teeming with life – but there are plenty of smaller towns and villages with a different kind of charm. Drive an hour east from Palermo and you’ll arrive at Cefalù – a laid-back town on the Tyrrhenian coast set against the dramatic backdrop of La Rocca, an 879ft (268m) cliff with a castle at the top.

In Taormina – an idyllic hilltop town on the east coast lined with medieval cobbled streets – you can visit the ancient Greek-Roman amphitheatre with spectacular vistas of Mount Etna and the Mediterranean. Venture up a little higher to Castelmola for an even better observation point.

In Sardinia, Cagliari is where you’ll find the richest selection of accommodation, restaurants and bars. It’s an attractive city which tends not to be overly crowded with tourists, and the historic centre – Quartiere Castello – is a delightful area to take a stroll. On the north coast, the harbour village of Castelsardo is especially eye-catching with a hilltop castle and colourful houses.

Island hopping

Unbeknown to some, Sicily is an island with its own set of islands. Reachable by ferry from Milazzo, the Aeolian archipelago comprises seven islands – each with a unique appeal. Sample the nightlife of Panarea, walk up an active volcano on Stromboli or soak in the mud baths and hot springs of Vulcano. A day trip to the Aegadian Islands off the northwest coast is also seriously worth considering to access secluded beaches and scenic nature trails.

Sardinia’s Maddalena archipelago shouldn’t be overlooked either. You’d be forgiven for thinking you’re in the Caribbean, with turquoise lagoons and swathes of unspoilt beaches – including Spiaggia Rosa renowned for having peculiar pink sand. It takes just 20 minutes to get there by ferry from Palau.

This is an updated rewrite of an article originally by Gillian McGuire .

Culture Trips launched in 2011 with a simple yet passionate mission: to inspire people to go beyond their boundaries and experience what makes a place, its people and its culture special and meaningful. We are proud that, for more than a decade, millions like you have trusted our award-winning recommendations by people who deeply understand what makes places and communities so special.

Our immersive trips , led by Local Insiders, are once-in-a-lifetime experiences and an invitation to travel the world with like-minded explorers. Our Travel Experts are on hand to help you make perfect memories. All our Trips are suitable for both solo travelers, couples and friends who want to explore the world together.?>

All our travel guides are curated by the Culture Trip team working in tandem with local experts. From unique experiences to essential tips on how to make the most of your future travels, we’ve got you covered.

Guides & Tips

The best private trips to book with your girl friends.

See & Do

Why san ginesio is one of the best tourism villages in the world.

The Best Trips and Tours in Italy

The Best Places to Travel in April 2024

Top Tips for Travelling in Italy

The Best Group Trips to Take With Your Partner

How Much Does a Trip to Italy Cost?

The Best Places to Travel in July

Visit the Locations from Your Favourite TV Shows with Culture Trip

Your Guide to Travelling Italy by Train

Top Tips for Travelling in Rome

The Most Amazing Markets in the World

Culture trip spring sale, save up to $1,656 on our unique small-group trips limited spots..

• Post ID: 1395297
• Sponsored? No
• View Payload

Sardinia or Sicily – Where to Travel Next

Home > Blog > Sardinia or Sicily – Where to Travel Next

Sardinia and  Sicily  are two of the most famous Italian island regions. They are both located in the Mediterranean Sea, both have distinctive cultures and thrilling histories, and both make ideal vacation destinations for those looking to explore a different side of Italy when they visit the country. 

But with so many similarities, choosing which place to visit is a tricky task. Each region has its own unique charm and outstanding features that will appeal to different kinds of traveller, but both are also outstanding destinations for a  beach holiday  and a chance to explore the  Italian coast .

To help guide your decision, here’s our rundown on choosing between visiting Sicily or Sardinia.

Sardinia is an island region of Italy that lies on the west coast of the country in the Mediterranean Sea. Evidence suggests that there have been inhabitants on Sardinia since the Neolithic times, with traces of a Bronze-Age community still found on the island in the form of large burial sites and massive stone columns.

After prospering for many years as a Mediterranean trading destination, between the 8th and 9th centuries B.C Sardinia was visited by people from other countries and cultures who began to settle on the island and influence its status. First came the Phonecians, who were attracted to the farming opportunities on the island and quickly developed several colonies.

In the 6th century B.C, Carthaginians arrived in Sardinia and began an invasion that left them with all the power. After many years of struggle between the inhabitants of the island, the Romans took control of Sardinia in 238 B.C and ruled for the next seven centuries.

The next significant historical event in Sardinia occurred at the start of the 11th century when troops from Pisa and Genoa ended the rule of Arab colonies on the island and trading massively opened up between the area and other parts of the Mediterranean. After falling under Catalonian rule in the 1400s, Sardinia eventually joined the unification of Italy in the late 1800s, although Catalan is still spoken in various places around the island.

Sardinia suffered from being exploited for its natural resources after it became a part of Italy, but the region was granted autonomy over infrastructure in 1948 which helped the island recover and become the prosperous vacation destination it still is today.

Sicily  is one of the best-known regions in Italy, characterised by the fact that it floats just off the ‘toe’ of the boot-shaped country. The island is the largest Italian region and has a long history that involves many different rulers and inhabitants that have all left their mark on the area.

The region was first significantly colonised by ancient Greek settlers in the 8th century B.C, building houses and temples that still partially remain around the island. In 212 B.C Roman troops invaded Sicily and took control of most of the region, ruling for six hundred years until the island was invaded again by Byzantine and then Arabic troupes.

Both of these cultures left lasting influences on the island’s inhabitants, with many examples of Arab and Byzantine art and architecture still found around Sicily today.

In 1071, Sicily experienced an era of political and economic prosperity after becoming an independent kingdom that was ruled by the Normans. This control lasted until the 17th century when the region was passed between several different countries and finally became a Spanish island right at the start of the 18th century.

After merging with Naples as a joint kingdom during Bourbon rule, Sicily joined the unification of Italy in the late 1800s. It was declared an autonomous region of the country in 1946, but still retains more Mediterranean and Greek influences than any other Italian location.

Both Sicily and Sardinia have a rich and fascinating history, with totally different backgrounds that make it hard to choose between the two. If you’re looking for classic historical sites and lots of Greek history then Sicily is the best option, whereas Sardina has much older examples of ancient monuments and has more Roman history than the other island.

The culture in  Sicily  is well known as being one of the most unique in the whole of Italy. This is due to the varied history of different inhabitants who have lived on and controlled the island over the past two thousand years, along with its position in the Mediterranean Sea. 

When it comes down to art, theatre and literature, Sicily has less of a cultural offering than many mainland Italian regions. There are a good array of museums, galleries and entertainment venues scattered across the island, but if you’re really after a cultural holiday then places like Rome and  Florence  have a lot more to see.

However, Sicily has a very distinct culture when it comes down to the way that locals live their life, combining elements of classic Italian culture with Greek and Mediterranean philosophy, food, politics and language. Religion is also an important part of life in the region, with celebrations around Easter and Christmas known for being particularly impressive.

Sardinian culture has also been influenced by its past inhabitants, along with a strong sense of autonomy from mainland Italy. Whilst Italian is the main language spoken on the island, the Sardinian language Sardo is still widely used, with different aspects varying between villages and towns.

There’s a strong sense of living life simply on Sardinia, so the island doesn’t have much of a cultural scene as past inhabitants tended to be farmers and traders who cared mostly about looking after the land. There’s a strong sense of pride in the island and the local culture however, with several cultural attractions in the larger towns and cities.

The Christian religion is also a big part of Sardinian culture, as it is across most of Italy, although many annual festivals and celebrations have an edge of pagan influence that stems from the island’s past as an agricultural destination.

Neither location stands out when it comes to things like art, theatre, music and literature, although Sicily is probably the better choice because it is the larger location and has more on offer in its cities. Both regions have their own unique culture and fierce pride about their islands, so you’ll find a different experience of Italian life whichever you visit.

ARCHITECTURE

The architecture of Sardinia is varied, with traces of all past inhibitors still found around the island. One of the most notable architectural highlights is the Nuraghe defensive buildings that are over a thousand years old and thought to have been built in the Bronze Age. There are around 7000 nuraghi to be found across Sardinia, in various states of preservation.

As in many Italian locations, Sardinia is home to a variety of churches built in Byzantine and Romanesque styles that are lovely to visit for an afternoon. Romanesque architecture features heavily across the island, with castles and towers dotted around Sardinia as well as plenty of cathedrals and churches. 

There are also a lot of examples of classic coastal architecture in Sardinia, with many towns consisting of pastel-coloured houses built up the cliffs and hills. 

The range of historical architecture in Sicily is outstanding, particularly when you consider that the island is relatively small in size. There are  ruins  from a wide range of eras including Byzantine, Arabic, African and Norman design, but the most impressive historic architecture is the ruins of Ancient Greek and Roman buildings.

An architectural highlight for many visitors to the island is  The Valley of the Temples ; a huge archaeological park that is home to numerous preserved ruins that were once ancient temples. Other must-see sites include the Sicily Archaeological Park, Roman ruins in Tindari, the acropolis ruins at Selinunte and the Taormina Amphitheatre.

When it comes down to architecture, Sicily is the best choice for a brilliant array of Greek and Roman ruins. Fans of Romanesque design will find a lot more to enjoy in Sardinia, and the famous Bronze Age structures are also a highlight if you have an interest in very early human history.

You’ll find plenty of classic Italian dishes around Sicily, but the region does have its own  distinct cuisine  that is heavily influenced by its geographic position and climate. On the coast you’ll find a delicious array of seafood, and elsewhere there is an emphasis on light flavours and vegetables, rice-based dishes like arancini, along with both mains and desserts that feature ricotta cheese as their signature ingredient.

Sicily is also known as being one of the  best vineyard regions  in Italy thanks to the incredibly fertile soil around Mount Etna, so if you’re a fan of fine wine then this is an excellent place to visit.

Sardinia has a similarly distinct cuisine that again has been influenced by the Mediterranean climate enjoyed by the island, its history of inhabitants and its proximity to other countries like France and Tunisia. As a past agricultural haven, the ingredients produced on the island are exceptional and many dishes focus on local produce like fish, cheese, fruit and bread. The seafood along the coast is excellent, and the  wine  produced in the region is also renowned.

Both Sicily and Sardinia offer a refreshing alternative to classic Italian cuisine if you visit either island, along with being excellent places for local wine.

If you don’t mind a lack of large, high-street brands then Sardinia is actually a relatively good place to go shopping whilst you’re on vacation. In big cities like Caligari, you’ll find a range of big shops selling everything from clothing to souvenirs, but in the  coastal towns  there are a great number of boutique places to buy plenty of items, particularly in fashionable Porto Cervo.

Sicily’s size means that it has a bigger range of shops suitable for all budgets, although you won’t find the same selection of boutique and designer brands as in larger and more fashionable locations like Rome,  Milan  or Naples. Neither location is a stand-out shopping destination, but both have their hidden gems and well-stocked shopping malls.

Sardinia is a particularly popular vacation destination with the rich and famous because it is beautiful, relatively small and doesn’t see as many tourists as places like  Rome , Venice and Milan. For this reason it has a bit of a reputation for being expensive, but you shouldn’t let this put you off coming to visit.

Whilst you can enjoy a luxurious holiday splashing your cash in Sardinia, it’s no more expensive than many other regions in Italy. Some areas are more exclusive and expensive than others, but there are plenty of coastal and central locations that have dining, activities and accommodation options suitable for all budgets.

When it comes down to cost,  Sicily  is a brilliant holiday destination if you are looking to try and save money when you are visiting Italy. If you’re after luxury then you have plenty of options for high-end hotels and self-catering properties, but there are also numerous budget-friendly hostels and holiday apartments that cater to everyone.

It’s also quite easy to find free or cheap things to see and do in Sicily, thanks to the wide range of beaches around the island and the variety of nature reserves and green spaces that are great for walking, cycling or other activities. You also don’t have to spend a lot of money on food if you cook for yourself and visit smaller, locally-owned restaurants, although again there are lots of options for higher-end dining if you want.

If you want a wider variety of budget-friendly things to do and places to stay, Sicily has the better choice out of the two islands. But neither is an exceptionally expensive destination, despite Sarfina’s reputation as a holiday spot for the rich and famous.

THINGS TO DO

Sicily is a brilliant destination choice if you like your vacation locations to offer a really wide variety of different things to see and do. There’s plenty of sightseeing opportunities,  beaches , sites with a fascinating history and lots of wild scenery to explore, along with the option to take day trips across to mainland Italy or other nearby islands.

Sardinia is known as being a top beach destination, so if you’re looking for an Italian vacation destination where you can spend all your time, swimming, sunbathing and soaking up the coastal atmosphere, this region is perfect. The beautiful landscape makes it a great place to enjoy outdoor activities on your holiday, whether you’re hiking, sailing, horse riding, cycling or exploring some of the historic sites around the island.

Sardinia is the best choice for the two locations for couples and travellers wanting  romance  or a bit more privacy on their trip, as it’s a less-touristy destination that has several exclusive holiday resorts and is known for attracting celebrities. It’s also the better choice for beach holidays, as many people believe the coast of Sardinia to be some of the most beautiful in all of Italy, with plenty of beaches and seaside towns to choose from.

If you’re looking for a jam-packed holiday itinerary then Sicily is the best choice for a destination that offers a range of things to keep you busy, whether you enjoy hiking, swimming, ancient history or wine tasting. Sicily’s distinctive culture gives visitors a different experience of Italy than other, classic locations and gives you the choice to spend time in cities, the countryside, the coast or a mix of all three.

If you’re thinking about a vacation to Sardinia or Sicily and would like the help  of an expert to plan a unique trip to one of these Italian islands,  get in touch  with Italy4Real for friendly advice and bespoke itineraries.

About the Author

Rem Malloy started Italy4real back in 1995 with his mother, Deborah de Maio.

He specialises in Italian tours as well as customised tours to France, England, Ireland, Germany, Switzerland, Greece and Spain. He was also featured in the Travel Channel show Mysteries at The Museum in 2016.

Rem has family in Italy and his mothers home town is Cava di Terrani, near the Amalfi Coast. The family has a street named after them in Sorrento, Via Luigi de Maio; a relative who was mayor of Sorrento.

Other Blog Posts You Might Like

Where to Stay in Venice: The Best Areas and Neighborhoods

When is the Best Time to Visit Florence?

When is the Best Time to Visit Venice?

What to Do in Florence for 3 Days 

The Best Foods in Sicily That You Need to Try

The 5 Best Day Trips from Florence 

Sardinia vs. Sicily

Similar or totally different.

Sardinia and Sicily are the most famous and biggest Italian islands. Their fame is due to different reasons, but sometimes, many foreigners get Sardinia and Sicily confused with one another.

Every aspect of what Sardinia and Sicily are , is in fact related to the sea and to the perfect idyll of the many different cultures that have left their mark on the Islands from age to age. Obviously, for lots of people, they are symbolized by sun and sea , but each of them have also thousands of different and interesting faces. As in each Italian region, the two Islands offer different cultural sites to visit , traditional recipes to taste and a strong identity that is a pity not to discover (and to confuse!).

So, let’s put things clear!

Where they are located? Are you sure to know where is Sardinia? and Sicily? Are you wondering: are they part of Italy?

Geographically speaking, Sardinia is the second largest island in the Mediterranean Sea, also considered (for its shape) the footprint of the “boat”. The nearest land masses is the island of Corsica while the 355 Km is the flight distance between Sardinia and Rome. Geographically speaking, Sicily is set in the Mediterranean, surrounded by sea. It is a triangular-shaped island to the west of Calabria, the toe of Italy's 'boot'. To reach Sicily there is a 20-minute ferry ride across the Strait of Messina from the Italian mainland. Nevertheless, in the literal and “social identity” senses of the question, both Sardinia and Sicily are two islands separate from the Italian mainland and, if you ask people here what their nationality is, though, you are just as likely to hear “ Sardinian ” and " Sicilian " as 'Italian'. Let the numbers speak ! - Total area Sardinia: 24,090 km2 Sicily: 25,711 km2 - Coastal development Sardinia: 1850 Km Sicily: 1500 Km - Density population Sardinia: 68/km2 Sicily: 200/km2

- Archipelagos and minor islands Sardinia: La Maddalena Archipelago, San Pietro, Sant’Antioco Sicily: Aegadian Islands, the Aeolian Islands, Pantelleria, Ustica  and Le Paleage

"Sardinia vs. Sicily" is not a real competition. The purpose of this post is to highlight the features that make them unique and intrigue you about their main common point: the beaches . In order to help you in finding your favorite beach... stay tuned and do not miss our next infographics about the best Sardinian and Sicilian beaches !

Suggested videos

Top 5 Italian Desserts: Traditional Sweets!

The best 5 beaches in Sardinia

Top 10 Traditional Foods in Sardinia

• Borgo Egnazia (Hotel) Puglia
• Zash Country Boutique Hotel & Spa (Hotel) Sicily
• Masseria Cervarolo (Hotel) Puglia
• Hôtel des Pecheurs – Corsica (Hotel) Sardinia
• Lupaia (Hotel) Tuscany
• Porto Cervo (Destination) Sardinia
• Taormina (Destination) Sicily
• Lecce (Destination) Puglia
• Palermo (Destination) Sicily

WHY BOOK WITH US ?

• Quality guaranteed
• Advice from experts
• Local assistance
• Secure payment

Suggested Hotels

• Destinations
• Travel Style
• Video Gallery
• Free Travel Guides
• Privacy & Cookies

© 2024 CharmingItaly.com is a trading name of Destination Italia S.p.A. Operational headquarters: Via San Tommaso D'Aquino, 18 - First Floor, Blue Tower - 09134 Cagliari, Sardinia (IT) Tel. +39.070.513489 Registration Regional Registry of Travel Agents n.110 - P.IVA 01127910915

Capri, Sicily and beyond: Which of the hundreds of Italian islands is best for your next vacation?

As the travel industry reopens following COVID-19 shutdowns, TPG suggests that you talk to your doctor, follow health officials' guidance and research local travel restrictions before booking that next trip. And we'll be here to help you prepare, whether it's next month or next year.

You've likely heard of (or maybe even visited) Italian islands like Sicily or Capri. But Italy has more than 450 islands, including both sea, lake , river and lagoon islands. Although not all of them are inhabited, many are sparsely populated and not too complicated to get to, making a socially distanced Italian island vacation a valid possibility at some point.

Whether it's a popular island like Sicily, a lake island such as Monte Isola or a relatively unknown island such as Lipari, Ponza or Elba, consider jetting off to Italy for an island getaway.

1. Naples Bay Islands, Campanian Archipelago and the Phlegraean Islands

Some of Italy's most accessible islands are reachable by a quick ferryboat from Naples: sophisticated Capri, the more local Ischia, quaint and colorful Procida, islet Nisida and the natural park of Vivara. Those wanting all the fancy glitz, glamour and tourist amenities (and prices to match) should head to Capri. For true Italian living, rent a scooter and explore Ischia's beaches and towering Aragonese castle .

Procida is tiny, but worth a day trip to wander the vibrant streets and check out the Palazzo d'Avalos, a former castle-turned-prison (it's now a historic attraction). From there, walk over the bridge to the island of Vivara, a natural reserve. Those with limited time in Naples can check out Nisida, a volcanic islet connected to the mainland by a stone bridge.

You've surely heard of the Mediterranean's largest island: Sicily. Although it's part of Italy, Sicily marches to the beat of its own Sicilian drum. The island is a fit for any traveler. Hikers will love trekking around Mount Etna and there are plenty of beaches around the island.

Wine-lovers can tour and taste Marsala and Nero D' Avola, Sicily's most famed varieties, and history buffs will immediately become enamored with the Baroque towns of the Val di Noto like Ragusa (which made our TPG U.K.'s most beautiful villages in Europe list ), Modica, Noto and Scicli. And no visit to the island is complete without a stop in the hilltop, coastal city of Taormina.

3. Pantelleria

Known as the "Black Pearl of the Mediterranean," this small volcanic islet is actually closer to Africa than Sicily. Pantelleria's rugged terrain and harsh climate of volcanic rocks, high winds and crashing waves don't fit the typical white sand, palm tree island image most tourists dream about.

But there's something intriguing about this far-flung landmass, which is known for growing capers, olives and Zibibbo grapes, which produce Passito dessert wine. Travelers wanting a little something different should plan to check it out.

4. Ponza and the Pontine Islands

When in Rome , do as the Romans do. And that means escaping the city's summer heat and heading to the Pontine Islands. The most popular is Ponza, and you can also visit Gavi, Palmarola, Santo Stefano, Ventotene and Zannone. From the San Felice Circeo port, you can reach Ponza in about an hour via hydrofoil. Ponza's attractions range from colorful villages to rocky grottos, but the other, lesser-visited islands deserve recognition too.

Ventotene is the next busiest island and one of the best spots in Italy for diving and snorkeling. Palmarola is also a prime spot to view underwater life, while hikers may prefer a day trip to the uninhabited island of Santo Stefano to explore.

5. Sardinia

As the second-largest island in the Mediterranean Island, Sardinia has many faces. Porto Cervo and the Costa Smeralda are where you'll find a more cosmopolitan yacht scene. Those wanting to social distance should head inland to hike and relax in the tranquil Gennargentu National Park.

You'll find stunning beaches around the entire island, but an ideal one for beach hopping is the quintessentially Italian village of Alghero which is surrounded by medieval walls. From there, you can explore some of the best sandy spots in the northeast of the island such as Stintino and the Maddalena Archipelago.

6. The Maddalena Archipelago

Some of the best beaches in Italy -- and in the world -- are located on the Maddalena Archipelago, made up of seven main islands plus varying smaller islets off the northern coast of Sardinia. Arrive via a 20-minute boat ride from the Sardinian port of Palau. The largest of the islands, Maddalena, is home to a pristine natural reserve which is best explored by kayak or canoe.

It's hard to pick a favorite beach (you may actually think you're in the Caribbean when you see the fine white sand and crystal clear waters), but Cala Coticcio on the island of Caprera and the pinkish sand of the Spiaggia Rosa are two of TPG's favorites.

7. The Tremiti Islands

San Domino, Cretaccio, San Nicola, Capraia and Pianosa are the Tremiti Islands. Situated off the Puglian coast in southern Italy, these islands have a truly remote feel -- so much so they made our TPG U.K. list of far-flung and obscure destinations to add to your bucket list.

We recommend checking out the two inhabited islands: the beaches of San Dominio, and the Santa Maria Abbey and fortress of San Nicola. Visitors heading to the islands outside of the main tourist season (summer) may find the beach coves hidden among the cliffs and pine trees entirely deserted.

Venice isn't just one island, it's actually made up of almost 120 different mini-islands, many of which are man-made. Before, summer would have been a crowded and expensive time to visit a spot like Venice , which has struggled immensely with over-tourism in recent years.

Due to shutdowns from coronavirus though, the waters of the Grand Canal and other waterways are much cleaner and clearer at the moment. In the future, you may find the islands of Venice a much calmer place to visit. Don't forget to check out some of Venice's lesser-visited island spots like brightly hued buildings of Burano and the famed blown glass in Murano.

9. Pelagian Islands

The Pelagian Islands are even closer to Africa than Pantelleria. The remote archipelago has three main islands: Lampedusa, Linosa, and Lampione. The largest, Lampedusa, is known for the Spiaggia dei Conigli, a beach which made the TPG U.K. best beaches of 2019 list . At the moment, the beach likely has more loggerhead turtle guests than human visitors.

You can fly to Lampedusa's small airport (LMP) from Rome or Milan. Linosa, known as the black island, has a few volcanoes . The tiniest island of Lampione is uninhabited except for a lone lighthouse, but its turquoise waters are incredible for diving and snorkeling.

10. Monte Isola

You may have heard of the popular Italian lakes Como and Garda, but Iseo, also located in northern Italy, is just as special. And in the middle of the lake you'll spot Monte Isola, a vibrant green mountain with pastel, red-roofed Italian buildings lining the base.

The car-free island, which can be reached via a quick ferry ride from nearby lake towns such as Sulzano is best lapped by bike. Although parts of the circular path are uphill, the views of the lake and neighboring Swiss Italian villages are incredibly charming. And if you get hot, just hop into the lake for a swim.

Related : Fast, scenic and the downright dirty: 5 European Interrail journeys I'll never forget

11. Elba, Giglio and the Tuscan Islands

The seven islands of the Tuscan National Park are Capraia, Elba, Giannutri, Giglio, Gorgona, Montecristo and Pianosa. The most famous and the third-largest island in Italy is Elba. Arrival includes flying to Pisa, driving a little over an hour to the port of Piombino and then catching a one-hour ferry to Elba. As the islands form a marine National Park, the beaches (both sand and rocky) are perfect for sun-seekers and divers and snorkelers . Hikers will also enjoy trekking many paths through the hills on the islands and a visit to the 18th-century Palazzina dei Mulini, Napolean's former residence, is a must. Giglio is best reached by ferry from the Port Santo Stefano, slightly further south than Piombino. You can spend the night or take a day trip, but make sure to visit the hilltop Giglio Castle and fortress.

Fans of "The Count of Montecristo" will understandably want to visit the exclusive island of Montecristo, but prepare for a long wait. You'll need a permit to enter and you may end up on a waiting list, so make sure to get your permit in advance -- only about 1,000 visitors are allowed per year. At any given time, there are probably more goats wandering the island than humans, as there are only a few residents who live there.

12. Aegadian Islands

Sicily's Aegadian Islands are located off the coast of Trapani and reachable by ferry. The main islands are Favignana, Levanzo, Marettimo, plus the smaller islets of Formica and Maraone. Favignana is the largest and easiest to get to, perfect for honeymooners looking for an exotic getaway in the times of COVID when perhaps getting to the Caribbean or another far-flung destination may not be a possibility. Couples can enjoy the clear waters of serene beaches like Cala Rossa and attractions like Grotta degli Innamorati (Lover's Grotto), as well as other intimate escapes around the island.

Levanzo's rugged coastline may be best for walkers and those really wanting to relax as there aren't too many shops or restaurants. And Marettimo, a car-free island, is even tinier and wilder, with hills, pine forests and hidden beaches.

13. Lipari and the Aeolian Islands

The island of Sicily has a number of nearby islands that are popular among Italians and relatively unknown to international tourists. The volcanic Aeolian archipelago consists of Lipari, Vulcano, Salina, Stromboli, Filicudi, Alicudi and Panarea. Lipari is the largest and most popular. Boating into its charming pastel-colored marina, with the Lipari castle perched on a cliff rising out of the water, feels like you've stepped back in time. Panarea (sometimes called the secret Santorini) is the smallest island, but perhaps the fanciest with a more exclusive, sophisticated feel.

Outdoor enthusiasts will love Vulcano, where you can hike craters and Stromboli, which features an active volcano. Salina is known for having a boutique hotel and a food and wine scene (sip a Malvasia in Malfa). You may recall seeing it in scenes from the 1994 film "Il Postino". Those who really want to get off the beaten path should head to remote islands of Alicudi and Filicudi, which are the furthest from Sicily -- you'll get around by donkey in some spots.

Bottom line

Italian islands offer visitors so much: Italian charm on island time. From popular islands like Capri or Sicily to virtually unknown spots like Filicudi or San Nicola, Italy's islands offer some of the best cuisine, beaches and Mediterranean magic in the country. So instead of a visit to Florence or Rome , consider an island vacation instead. If you love hiking, wine, food, exploring, diving or sunbathing, Italy's got an island (or several) right for you.

7 of the best places to cruise in Italy

F ew countries can compete with Italy’s tourist appeal . Anyone who visits can enjoy fantastic cities, quaint villages, a string of picture-perfect coastlines, amazing cuisine and a fascinating history.

Alhough skiing , city breaks or a trip to one of the Italian lakes all have their own merits, there is a way to get a taste of several different parts of the country in one whirlwind trip.

Cruises around the Bel Paese give passengers the opportunity to see Italy ’s full range of sights. You can start with the romance of Venice and wind around to the rugged island beauty of Sicily and Sardinia, or begin surrounded by the stark coastal beauty of the Cinque Terre and end in hectic, characterful Naples , via the enchanting capital of Rome .

Whether you just want to see one destination or a handful, there’s likely a cruise to suit you; we’ve rounded up some of the best below.

Amalfi Coast

The Amalfi Coast contains a little bit of everything that has made Italy so famous: beautiful coastlines, golden sands, picturesque towns, ancient historic sites and a hearty slice of la dolce vita .

The main towns along this coast include Amalfi, Sorrento and Positano , each renowned for offering a taste of the highlife in often luxurious surroundings, whether that be laid-back beaches or grandiose hotels. Pompeii lies close to these towns, offering an incredible insight into a famous bit of world history, while driving part of the Amalfi Coast’s winding roads is the best way to get amazing views while taking in some delightful towns.

How to do it

See both Sicily and the Amalfi Coast with the ‘ Amalfi & Sicily ’ seven-night package offered by Star Clippers. It starts in Civitavecchia, taking you to Amalfi and Sorrento before moving on to Messina and circling back to Rome.

Prices from £3,629pp including seven nights’ accommodation, all meals and drinks and select entertainment. Departing 6 July 2024.

Read more on the best hotels on the Amalfi coast

The capital is a beautiful fusion of historic and contemporary Italian life, from the modern cuisine and nightlife of Monti to the old houses and trattorias of Trastevere or Parione.

The Eternal City is also Europe’s most landmark-filled destination , with everything from Roman ruins to 18th-century fountains. The Colosseum, Roman Forum and Pantheon are the undoubtably highlights, as are the Spanish Steps and Trevi Fountain. The Vatican City is also contained within Rome, and you don’t want to miss the Sistine Chapel or St Peter’s Basilica.

Most cruises to this part of the country actually dock at nearby Civitavecchia, which is roughly one hour from the capital. Rome is often a starting point for cruises too, as passengers can head north to the Cinque Terre, east to Sardinia and south to Naples and Sicily.

The  Italian Treasures  cruise offered by Atlas Ocean Voyages begins in Valletta , the historic Maltese capital, but after departing very much focuses on the eastern Italian coast. It stops for a night in both Syracuse and Giardini Naxos (on Sicily), before departing to the Amalfi Coast and Capri and then finishing in the capital, where you can explore at your leisure before flying home.

Prices from £2,946pp including eight nights’ accommodation, all meals and drinks and onshore excursions. The company is currently running a promotion where the ‘second guest sails free’, so it is possible to get the entire package for just £2,946. Departing 1 September 2024.

Read more on the best hotels in Rome

Venice is perhaps the most beautiful of all Italian cities, situated on a vast lagoon and criss-crossed by dozens of bridges that hang over its canals. Its waterways are lined with the colourful facades of centuries-old buildings, many of which carry a Venetian style that is unique to the city, making for an eclectic cityscape.

A gondola trip, a stroll around St Mark’s Square, a walk over the Ponte Rialto and a visit to the Doge’s Palace are customary for those seeing the city for the first time, though for many the real attraction is getting lost in the sea of mazy alleys and historic bridges .

Many cruises start and end in Venice too, though due to its location at the top of the Adriatic, it can take a while to cruise down to other popular destinations like Bari, Sicily and the Amalfi Coast. If you’re visiting on a cruise, chances are it’ll be a longer one, or that it’ll stop in destinations in northern Croatia , Dubrovnik or northern Greece .

Azmara Cruises’ ‘ Italy Intensive Voyage ’ takes passengers all the way from Rome to Venice. It begins by going north to Florence , then turning back on itself and going south to the Amalfi Coast and Sicily. After a brief stop in Kotor, Montenegro , you’ll finish in Venice, with the opportunity to explore at your leisure before flying home.

Prices from £2,060pp including 10 nights’ accommodation, all meals and drinks, evening entertainment and select onshore excursions. Departing 10 April 2024.

Read more on the best hotels in Venice

Sicily is another of Italy’s famous islands, sharing a part of the Mediterranean with neighbouring Sardinia. It is equally as charming as Sardinia, and filled with similarly beguiling towns, a variety of natural landscapes and some of the finest culture and history that the country has to offer.

Tradition is paramount here, something that is reflected in a proud local populace. It is also visible in towns and cities like Palermo, and the timeless beauty of Syracuse, as well as on the olive groves and vineyards that dot the slopes of Mount Etna. It makes Sicily a great place to come if you want to see modern-day Italian living with a dose of outdoor adventure, in places like the Parco dell’Etna, along with historic charm (such as that at Syracuse).

Windstar Cruises’ ‘ Sicilian Spendours ’ cruise begins and ends in the Italian capital, but as the name suggests, this trip very much focuses on the largest island in the Mediterranean. It begins by heading to the Amalfi Coast, but then moves on to three Sicilian towns – Trapani, Porto Empedocle and Catania, via Gozo and Malta .

Prices from £3,105pp including 10 nights’ accommodation, meals and onboard entertainment. Departing 28 May 2024.

Read more on the best hotels in Sicily

Sardinia, which sits off the eastern coast around six hours from Civitavecchia by ferry, is one of Italy’s most popular summer destinations. A favourite among both tourists and Italians, it is home to a slew of great beaches – including Cala Goloritzé and the Costa Smerelda – and so is a good choice for days spent flitting between water sports and lying in the sun.

Though it’s understandable if you want to spend most of your time here on the sands, it would be remiss not to visit some of the pastel-hued towns and verdant national parks that lie inland and on the coast. Places like Alghero, Bosa and San Teodoro contain plenty of history throughout their cobbled streets, while Asinara and Gennargentu are two of the most picturesque natural areas.

Sardinia’s southerly location means that cruises that stop here often carry on to Sicily and Malta, and may go further on to the Balearics, Greek islands or even Tunisia .

The ‘ Enchanting Italian Coastlines ’ tour from Emerald Cruises covers both Sardinia and the eastern coast over a period of seven nights. It begins in the capital, moving first to Sorrento and Amalfi and then crossing the Mediterranean to Sardinia and Corsica before looping back.

Prices from £3,379pp including seven nights’ accommodation, all meals and drinks and airport transfers. Departing 27 April 2024.

Cinque Terre

The Cinque Terre competes with the Amalfi Coast for the title of Italy’s most famous coastal area, but the Italian Riviera offers a different kind of beauty in its emerald waters and pastel-coloured towns. The region is part of Liguria, and consists of five villages: Monterosso al Mare, Vernazza, Corniglia, Manarola, and Riomaggiore. 

Each one has an abundance of old Italian charm, from the faded colours that come alive at sunset to the mazes of alleys leading up from tiny harbours. Only Monterosso has a proper beach, but this village quintet isn’t the place for solely a beach holiday, despite the coastlines. Instead, wander aimlessly through the villages, enjoy a laid-back meal or take to any of the surrounding hiking paths.

These once isolated villages are now tourist hotspots in their own right, with the Cinque Terre Express one of the best ways to get between them. Most cruises dock at La Spezia, the province’s main city, which lies just 20 minutes from the nearest Cinque Terre village, Riomaggiore.

The Cinque Terre is a less frequented destination on longer cruises, so the best bet is to visit as part of a multi-country cruise. Celebrity Cruises offers one such option with their ‘ Italian Riviera & France ’ package, which departs from Rome and initially heads south to Naples before circling around to La Spezia and Santa Margherita. After some time spent enjoying the Italian Riviera, you move on to the French one, seeing Cannes and Marseille before finishing in Barcelona.

Prices from £1,209pp including nine nights’ accommodation, return flights, all meals, daily activities and entertainment. Departing 4 June 2024.

Naples is a fascinating city, buoyed by a vibrant and chaotic energy and blessed with beautiful surroundings – including Mount Vesuvius and an azure bay – and an eclectic blend of architecture.

The city itself has a wealth of culture and history, from the recent and immaterial – such as its devotion to pizza or its football club – to the ancient and pertinent, including the Duomo cathedral and a large collection of Greco-Roman artefacts at the National Archaeological Museum. Be sure to talk a walk around the Spanish Quarter, Centro Storico and Spaccanapoli (the city’s main thoroughfare) to get a real sense of how life is lived in this hectic city.

Naples is the closest major city to the Amalfi Coast, and as such many trips here are combined with a visit to towns like Sorrento or Positano.

You’re spoilt for choice when including Naples in a cruise itinerary, and many cruises that stop here also include visits to parts of Greece and Croatia. A seven-day Mediterranean cruise from Norwegian Cruise Line takes advantage of these stops, taking guests from Rome to Venice via Valletta, Split and Corfu. Nevertheless, the focus is still on Italy, taking in the historic capital, the romantic canals of Venice and all of Naples’ characterful chaos (with an added stop in Messina, Sicily).

Prices from £1,573pp including seven nights’ accommodation, all meals and drinks and onboard entertainment. Departing 14 August 2024.

The Independent is the world’s most free-thinking news brand, providing global news, commentary and analysis for the independently-minded. We have grown a huge, global readership of independently minded individuals, who value our trusted voice and commitment to positive change. Our mission, making change happen, has never been as important as it is today.

• Sicily Tourism
• Sicily Hotels
• Sicily Bed and Breakfast
• Sicily Vacation Rentals
• Flights to Sicily
• Sicily Restaurants
• Things to Do in Sicily
• Sicily Travel Forum
• Sicily Photos
• All Sicily Hotels
• Sicily Hotel Deals
• Last Minute Hotels in Sicily
• Things to Do
• Restaurants
• Vacation Rentals
• Travel Stories
• Rental Cars
• Add a Place
• Travel Forum
• Travelers' Choice
• Help Center

Ortigia or Siracusa Hotel/Apartment - Sicily Forum

• Europe    
• Italy    
• Sicily    

Ortigia or Siracusa Hotel/Apartment

• United States Forums
• Europe Forums
• Canada Forums
• Asia Forums
• Central America Forums
• Africa Forums
• Caribbean Forums
• Mexico Forums
• South Pacific Forums
• South America Forums
• Middle East Forums
• Honeymoons and Romance
• Business Travel
• Train Travel
• Traveling With Disabilities
• Tripadvisor Support
• Solo Travel
• Bargain Travel
• Timeshares / Vacation Rentals
• Italy forums
• Sicily forum

Visiting Sicily in June for the first time.

Our Airbnb has just cancelled our stay so I’m looking for accommodation.

4 replies to this topic

Anna, wait for Vagabonda, who is stellar Destination Expert, to reply and don’t listen to those who try to discourage you. You just can’t go wrong with Vagabonda’s advice.

https://www.tripadvisor.com/Hotels-g187891-zfa3-a_ufe.true-Syracuse_Province_of_Syracuse_Sicily-Hotels.html

Enjoy your trip!

Amazing thank you for your help :)

We would just love a hotel with a pool as I know my daughter will really enjoy it

• Avoid carriage rides and animal abuse 9:49 am
• In Taormina Now Wife and child 6..things to do 9:33 am
• Van Hire 7:10 am
• 12 nights, 13 days in Sicily with a mostly clean slate 1:02 am
• Mangia's Brucoli yesterday
• Transfer from Palermo yesterday
• Catania Airport - Discover cars yesterday
• First time to Sicily advice on hotels and area needed yesterday
• Scaffolding in Duomo yesterday
• Torn between Siracusa (and south), Licata towards and Tropea yesterday
• Airport transfers yesterday
• Palermo vs Cefalu as a base? yesterday
• Three nights with three children in late June yesterday
• Ortigia or Siracusa Hotel/Apartment yesterday
• Best beaches in Sicily 3 replies
• 7-10 days in sicily - best places to go? 19 replies
• Winter In Sicily? 13 replies
• Beach resorts 5 replies
• Ferries from Naples to Palermo 6 replies
• Are there any family beach hotels / resorts in Sicily 10 replies
• Driving in Sicily 12 replies
• Best time to go to Sicily 6 replies
• What part of Sicily to stay in? 7 replies
• Taormina/Agrigento/Siracusa Drive 12 replies

Sicily Hotels and Places to Stay